Chanukah: The Menorah Lasts Forever - The Astounding Chidush of Rav Yehoshua M'Kutna (Audio Only)

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we have one little piece of the gamar describing the miracle of kanuk the gamar just tells us that on the 25th day of are eight days of Kan they came into the they only found enough oil for one day it lasted eight days says so what did they do they established we say we say the gar forgot to mention the most important part of kanuka you know never says you like the the whole G that talks about it never said you say it says you say it says you say what happened the only reason theab even speaks about kanuka because it it speaks about lighting the Shabbat so talks about kanuka but when it comes down to it and it says what's kanuka it left out you light the there was a great gaon in Poland my grandfather's grandfather was a student of Rua lutna he writes in the times of kanuka they never made a Mitzvah of liting the man why would they make a MIT the mikd was standing they lit the in the mikdash why would they say light the in your house later 200 years later when the temple was destroyed the rabbi said to commemorate kanuka like light the man on your house they never said it

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01we have one little piece of the gamar describing the miracle of kanuk the gamar just…
2. 0:32the the whole G that talks about it never said you say it says you say…
3. 1:03grandfather's grandfather was a student of Rua lutna he writes in the times of kanuka they…
4. 1:33originally very interesting that's why the gar doesn't mention it if you look in the r…
5. 2:03legislation it comes down now we understand we know that when they inaugurated the m and…
6. 2:35them how did that console what does that mean in the future theah that's aah how…
7. 3:06going to continue in your home meaning when you light the in your home it's not…
8. 3:36today there's a you can't get you can't use you can't count your money by the…
9. 4:08eight days to transform our home into aash that we could light the so we should…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.