Chanukah: How Did the Greeks Make the Oil Impure?

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

they only found one jug of oil the acharyan asked the following question they asked they went into the azara now the gemara tells us that the azara had a dinner versus yeah a public domain after all it was opened to guyana of sweden anyone could go into the azar it was now what's that if you have a case of sufficient sarabin if you're unsure if something is tami or taha now we learned that from saitai if a woman goes into seclusion with a man and it's just that in a private place we don't know what happened we assumed something bad happened if it was public we don't assume that i don't understand how do we know the ivana defiled all the oil in the hay file well we have fingerprints on them no we just we're not sure where they were not preserved the torah but we don't have you know dna evidence that the kashmir touched it that the ivana touched it so if that's the case we should apply the rule suffix versus so why did i have to make a miracle use the oil you tell me but maybe they were matami suffice is tahr that's a good question who says they kept the oil on there in the azara maybe they kept it in some private closet so if you look in the gemaran shabbos and that huff base on the base where they go where this gemara is mentioned on the side of the page you have a footnote from rabbi akiva heger and rubiki vager and they go right take a look where you're learning shabbos and adafyoni [Laughter] so let's look there so you have on your sheet look in aleph on the second paragraph nura shalom had gone right but this would seem to be what riba kireiger's bothered by the guyana on the place

Jump to a moment

1. 0:39they only found one jug of oil the acharyan asked the following question they asked they…
2. 1:41we have fingerprints on them no we just we're not sure where they were not preserved…
3. 3:28they had four chambers on the four corners of the azar maharava's dromus in the southwest…
4. 5:17pass out that there was room for everybody but it had the halal status of rishi…
5. 6:53he wants to say that when the gemara says it doesn't mean that we're unsure exactly…
6. 8:24is that's what the rashford says one second exactly it's not possible it's not possible so…
7. 9:25it's wide enough it would be uh sticker was just but not for this so think…
8. 10:57the tahara are not dependent on the laws of israel for for shabbos so even if…
9. 12:27brings down from the you shall me that it's a kava climber are you ready for…
10. 14:30[Applause] so once the night came everything became tiny this is what's brought down in the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.