Armeedienst für Talmidei Chachamim und Bnei Yeshivos?

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Dovid Gernetz’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Okay, welcome everyone, live and online. Topic time: The topic is: Do they have to join the army? Yes, the question is, do they have to join? This is a political question to discuss here. Do they have to join the army? Yes, very much so. Yes, everyone has heard about this. About two weeks ago, the Supreme Court decided that they have to join Supreme Court decided that they have to join the army. Since about the founding of the State of Israel, the status quo has been that they don't have to join. I think it was established sometime in the 90s. There was a committee against it. An objection was raised as to why they should go, and it was decided that they don't have to go. They have to report for duty, go. They have to report for duty, but they get a pension every year. And two and a half weeks ago, it was decided that this is n't fair. It's not against the constitution, and that's why they have to join the army. The question is, what does the [unclear] say? What does the [ unclear] say about this question? And we'll see very clearly that they don't have to join. And this [unclear] begins. You can begin it. It stands after the [unclear] people say, go to war against [unclear] and [unclear] the honor of [unclear], [unclear ] the whole thing. The whole thing was over and the war was also over and also in the war, this repeated repetition, simply 1000 per still, and it went quickly, an opinion, why do you need 3000, and this opinion says they watched over those who had the

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01Okay, welcome everyone, live and online. Topic time: The topic is: Do they have to join…
2. 4:32watched over the K or helped somehow, and there were always 1000, they prayed for the…
3. 8:48differences, right? Or you could say he even means the... and someone who takes on expensive...…
4. 13:19this picture, someone who does it is punished, some, even some more, in a very, very…
5. 17:49[music] with the gem, it doesn't seem as simple as D the king, he may be…
6. 22:18he says it's about saving people and if this isn't there, then people are endangered and…
7. 27:01anyone who is not in war, he should not be considered, someone who tries to run…
8. 31:04Chief R writes that a Chief Rab is the one who separates himself from them, he…
9. 35:09first world war, but of course he would say that when it comes to Israel it's…
10. 39:30also be there in SE. He is of the opinion that one must not do it,…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.