Hoshana Rabba Today: More Critical Than Ever

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

shannara so you think it's probably gemara somewhere and maybe in a sector i never learned no it's not there's no gemara anywhere in shas that says anything about hashana rabbah it's probably you xiaomi right no there's not one you shall me nowhere nothing in the babyli nothing new xiaomi nothing in so where did it come from there's a concept that even though yom kippur is a young kappa is like the final chance the last chance it's also a kin to your kit but it's almost like yum kippur itself so in fact what we have here is we have two days on the calendar we have a day of yum kippur we have a day of hashana rabbo that are almost equal why do we need two days first of all why do we need two days well yom kippur isn't good enough why can't your kipper do the job and why does the torah not say anything about hashana rabbah so raphael mcclugger has a very ingenious approach to this problem and ursula cougar says like this the gemara tells us that yom kippur does not work until you made it through the day in other words says the gemara if someone passes away the night of yom kippur they don't get kapara the kapara of yom kippur only takes place in the daytime in fact if hanan wasserman writes that if you look in the historical accounts of the goinim one of the gaainam it says cast away the night of yom kippur

Jump to a moment

1. 0:30shannara so you think it's probably gemara somewhere and maybe in a sector i never learned…
2. 2:33but when it comes to hashana rabbah night right at night everyone's staying up all night…
3. 5:08what is the main indictment against the yet what is the main thing a person has…
4. 7:08learn gemara do we learn tarshiva so therefore hashanah is left to the torah shabbat to…
5. 9:41hashem is judging how much money he's going to make or how much paranoia he's going…
6. 11:46and they say no you can't learn lara yata you may tilt it so jakub kaminsky…
7. 14:19can't do business on channels why it's a gazero you may come to write so wait…
8. 16:24that right now the rebound is deciding exactly how the year is going to be how…
9. 18:58it means absolutely nothing it doesn't mean anything to us we don't feel it we're not…
10. 21:01movement yeah so says jakob kaminetsky the reason why hoshanah rabbo was not revealed until the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.