Causing a Melachah to Occur on Shabbat - גרמא בשבת - A Shiur By Rav Asher Weiss Shlit"a

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Asher Weiss’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

if i need to make a list of three suggestions which to me are most complicated grommet would definitely be either number one two or three it is one of the most broad based suggestions it affects so many different areas i will not be addressing today the general topic of goroma that requires more than one shear it's a cigar which a coil a full day cradle needs to learn at least for six months and therefore i will be focusing on shabbos which is one enough one branch of the brother of grammar and even this is extremely complicated but it also has huge practical implications huge so the basic suggestion for many days [Music] and the gemura clearly explains why it's there's a fire in your home and you naturally want to extinguish that fire put out that fire so if we're dealing with the pikachu fish goes without saying take a water hose take a pail and put out the fire it's not it because in every situation you could take your kids and your wife and leave the house and just sit outside and watch the spectacle your house burned down but it's not a very happy proposition so hazal deal with the question is there a way to put out that fire which would be permissible which wouldn't be an issue the governor says yes there is so you take all the cliches you have in your house you fill them up with water you put them around a perimeter surrounding the fire so when the fire will get bigger the heat will become more intense those vessels ultimately will disintegrate

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00if i need to make a list of three suggestions which to me are most complicated…
2. 4:43considered and why is this so important it's important because in our day and age uh…
3. 9:26it's the easiest or the most lenient is that we have in our societies because even…
4. 14:17limited but a collision gave him brains far beyond what he bestowed upon any other creature…
5. 18:59dams utilizing the awesome power of falling water of running water rivers waterfalls dams so since…
6. 23:46rashi and rush what i just explained in the past few minutes i think that's a…
7. 28:28the horizon unless his clear intention and primary goal is the malacha so when you put…
8. 32:37fire the craziest way to do it is to fill up kitten with water and put…
9. 37:23so between pressing the button and having the engine go on usually it's a second or…
10. 42:35one last comment which is an extremely powerful comment in my opinion and this goes back…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.