Noach - Are you putting forward the right arguments?

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Dovid Eisenberg’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

tremendous amounts of great great stuff here we got iris coming back in okay we're going to deal today with specifically with there is a famous rashi one of the most famous rashis i think that that everybody knows about hi sorry there's a famous rashi that we're going to deal with and the the positive says the following right at the beginning of the passage of noah we say ayla told us these are either the children or these are the happenings that happen to noah and then right away as we describe noah we say was a man who was exotic a righteous person tom him wholesome right so he was in his generations with god or together with god not what that's how we start off the parasha of nach and then we say no has three children shame come in the office and the world has become entirely corrupted et cetera et cetera so why do we have to say that noah was a sadiq tominvidarosov why did we have to tell you that noah was a righteous person but a righteous person in his generations what we really person in his generations what we really should be saying to you is not was a righteous person period why are we mentioning his generations so she right away tells us those that say this is a positive message that's being given in the yashadasana secondary and some say no this is a very negative message so number one if you go say that

Jump to a moment

1. 0:39tremendous amounts of great great stuff here we got iris coming back in okay we're going…
2. 3:44that actually the two opinions in rashi are not disagreeing with each other they're actually both…
3. 6:48generation struggles with different things and therefore if you want to help that generation with their…
4. 9:50mistake in that logic i said well tell me what the mistake is you can't just…
5. 12:54they would change their life there are people like that but i think that those people…
6. 15:58one of you call it the shear passion the tools for the modern woman you might…
7. 19:02go oh this guy's crazy he's not he's just very brutally honest because even if a…
8. 22:04and to bring it out to people and if you didn't catch after 120 years that…
9. 25:11wealthiest guy in the council of state you know what you say to the guy sugarner…
10. 28:18morning lots of my friends don't come every shop this morning and i will come every…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.