Rabbi Raymond Haber - Shabbat Daf 39 Lamed Tet

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Raymond Haber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

okay we're starting on the bottom of says they asked the question to if he forgot a pot on top of thebat and it cooked on Shabbat so from the fact that it says that it cooked on Shabbat we see that the pot wasn't yet fully cooked right it wasn't fully fully cooked right it wasn't fully cooked he forgot it on the and the wasn't and it doesn't make a difference to says whether you hold like says that we're talking according to the that disagree with Kan says even if you hold like Kan and you're allowed to leave on a pot which is which is over here we're asking where he left the part that's that's not it started to cook because if it's raw you're allowed to leave it anyway it's you're allowed to leave it anyway it's not raw it started to cook but it didn't get it's not a third away cook so it's ass according to so it was definitely ass to leave it there the question is does leaving a PO that's that's not so didn't answer tell him anything the next day he had give he told them the the is like this give he told them the the is like this we have a that says not the same case if I cook food on shab mistake you could eat it on Shabbat we don't hold like this this is this is the they told them if he cooks he can't eat it that's talking if he cooked on Shabbat over here he's cooked he he put it on he left it before Shabbat there's no difference in this

Jump to a moment

1. 0:02okay we're starting on the bottom of says they asked the question to if he forgot…
2. 6:27that if it wasn't fully cooked so you all leaving it on the fire over Shabbat…
3. 12:49leave so what is it does only over there to leave over here meaning over here…
4. 19:10it's he thinks the question is if it's fully cooked what that's like no fully cooked…
5. 25:55not got he found that they left hot water on the fire without he wasn't for…
6. 32:15back in the day when you take it off people will think you took it off…
7. 38:43GOI says not now let's see that he was who was the last guy that did…
8. 45:15else table could beut according to someone to say someone to say that a countertop that's…
9. 51:39pulp then it has a of and you can't do anything with it take the Mish…
10. 57:58you put one pot on top where you put two pots we have a that teaches…

Every second of this shiur plays inside FilteredTube — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.