A Judge Can Only Rule by the Information He Has - A Shiur By Rav Asher Weiss Shlit"a

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Asher Weiss’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

so this week we start mishna toyota and in the beginning of the pasha moshirobano teaches some of the fundamentals of din zedek the mishpot and the sugar we will be discussing today is one of the most fundamental usaidis in turishova ainle dayan ella marcia enova roys that's an expression we find three times that's an expression we find three times in sanhedrin that's not the proper order but that will be the order of today's shira we will define each of these three sugyas so what does that mean let's start with the weekly partial so my charabano tells the people i put together a hierarchy of daiyonim just listens to what the parties have to say and then decides who's right but sometimes the diane has to listen carefully what the party said and what they did not say not only what they said but how they said and sometimes the conclusion is very different than what any of the parties really argued and in that case the dionys the pascan and in that case the dionys the pascan the fiat zedek and naklafi hamishbot because justice and law are not always the same and not always do they coincide means listen to what happens between the parties and sadek is not necessarily mishpot and that is a new interpretation you need to judge according to what you see subjectively not what the parties argued what you analyze and you understand and you conclude and he quotes so i'm putting the arachim aside for a few minutes and i want to explain the three suggestions what an awesome responsibility is to be what an awesome responsibility is to be a dying again

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00so this week we start mishna toyota and in the beginning of the pasha moshirobano teaches…
2. 3:44says and you do your best you have nothing to be afraid of velone and us…
3. 8:02talmud so that ramban and iran draw a comparison like a dying you did your best…
4. 11:36always right and maybe the al-fasi the great rabbenu maybe here he's not right the same…
5. 14:47into it we're not learning because they own him today but that's what the rambam says…
6. 18:26we have far more information far more data than they ever had but the great minds…
7. 22:14how far do we take this so would we say a love that disagrees with the…
8. 25:44baby they were there to be them but same same generation in that case the talmud…
9. 29:20the previous generation there definitely is a difference in in in style in tone between the…
10. 33:12so if it's not a kesha or man we could be mako says we're not boki…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.