Understanding Proxy Observance in Commandments (שליחות במצוות) | Shiur by Harav Asher Weiss Shlita

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Asher Weiss’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

so today as you see we have a somewhat different schedule than we usually have ER of shabas um I was somewhere else and I gave it she this morning so the sugar we will be briefly discussing today is one of the most widely discussed sugis in Chas and that isz what does it have to do with this week's Para the ask how do we know there's a concept of the brings three sources we don't have the entire Gora just the beginning of thein and that's this week's and thousand people can do together asks to which does apply and to which mitz does not apply Source number two on our sheet yes person has a very busy day and he doesn't have time to put on could he make a you know put on for me it's ridiculous so why could you make to circumcise his child and he can't make to sit in the OR to put on so many understand that the t means to say there's a certain category certain type of mitvah which is defined MIT a Mitzvah that a person is to perform actually with his own body and therefore schas wouldn't apply so is the difficulty is how do we determine which mitz would be defined as a mitz and which mitv not necessarily about your your hands or your feet or your shoulder or your body just things got to be done and many other great deal with this question Sam which is Source number four is somewhat of a surprise and the says would apply to every mitah unless there is a that does not apply for instance does anybody remember about so right in middle of this paragraph he deals with the what he asks from first says second par is

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00so today as you see we have a somewhat different schedule than we usually have ER…
2. 3:58about so right in middle of this paragraph he deals with the what he asks from…
3. 8:06here there are two different categories of mitv say some mitv are just to achieve a…
4. 11:51essence are either s or stage number two all the mitz that are would never apply…
5. 15:26to drive to the HOA so the says there are two options she could light candles…
6. 19:13that so from this last B we learn when it's all about the result you don't…
7. 22:51that the resultes but every sensible person understands that the actual will act is the says…
8. 26:31maybe it not be relevant and when my baby is born it's a bit too late…
9. 30:1913 Even children pay the price and on the other hand and we need to go…
10. 33:59never saw myself as a king and AES says you are a king that is kingship…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.