Rabbi Dr. David Gottlieb - Jewish Philosophy: What About Emotions?

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Hidabroot - Torah & Judaism’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

there are some subjects which don't get too much attention from jewish writers surely not too much from jewish thinkers and one of them is the emotions my reviews that sound the boston heavy work to a great extent about emotions and i'll explain to you as we go along why and some of the things that he said but um i want to do just a little bit of philosophical background to set the stage there was a very common view of philosophy say 300 years ago and i think it's largely been outgrown though you might find it here and there and that is emotions are just things that happen to people they just happen in fact uh 300 years ago the word for emotions was passions the word passion comes from a root meaning passivity it just happens something that happens to you it happens that happens there'll be no way to talk about it as being right or wrong certainly couldn't have any rules about emotions what voices you should or should not have they're impossible to control they're just things that happen to you like catching the flu it happens you might have to deal with it but it's just something that happens well people did appreciate that in one respect you could talk about emotions as unfortunate because some emotions prompt you to act in certain ways sometimes the way you act might be productive might be healthy worthwhile and sometimes not certain emotions produce certain actions quite regularly and sometimes the world in which we live needs those actions we need those actions sometimes not that's like fear generates defensive behavior either trying to protect oneself or running away that's great if you're in danger then running away or defending yourself is useful behavior

Jump to a moment

1. 0:21there are some subjects which don't get too much attention from jewish writers surely not too…
2. 6:19certain logic about them and that means can't just regard them as something that happens a…
3. 12:03um one of the examples that the talmud gives or something bad happening is you have…
4. 17:49the whole of the reality is good what blessing do you make you make the blessing…
5. 23:37body human being's identity is soul and body i have heard people even people who are…
6. 29:26explanations but i think this is one explanation of why the tradition tells us we have…
7. 35:19it's no ah lo that means he appreciates it it's pleasant to him it's good for…
8. 41:03that's to remind people of instruction to put a certain limit on the hilarity that could…
9. 46:54and commentary say not too much crying not too much crying and the lord talks about…
10. 52:40one of the mitzvos in the torah is to love to love god and to love…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.