Friendly Fire A Halachic Analysis 12 12 2025

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Yoel Plutchok’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Um, okay. We're going to continue what we started last week about talking about um, loosely army related army related chilus. Now, not everyone who's here now was here last week. So, I'll just give like a drop of recap. We mentioned that there is a historical perspective that suggests that the Kashmir did not do battle on Chabas. There's not just the Kashmir but many different Jewish armies throughout the generations it seems didn't do battle on Shabas. It seems to have been Mak. Now we raised the point that according to kazal the chabas and it's very clear that you're allowed to it's very clear that you're allowed to do battle on chavas. Not only are you allowed to it seems to be a very expansive that almost obligates you to do muham on chabas. So we came to the conclusion that um more than likely Israel did do battle on chabas and it was observers who were not fully educated in the nuance and the minutiae of chabas that presumed that whatever little detail they noticed was really that wasn't doing battles and essentially was actually battling on chabas. Now I want to like segue off that into a different angle. Now we we closed up last week by by bringing the Rambam that allows eating trafe during

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00Um, okay. We're going to continue what we started last week about talking about um, loosely…
2. 2:42all they did was hide. The only thing they knew to do was to hide and…
3. 5:16nothing to is it's even if it's not he says on no uncertain terms this is…
4. 7:50on topic these days about uh what what exactly is the responsibilities of someone who kills…
5. 10:22accident. He uh I don't remember what the story was and he told the guy to…
6. 12:58has all the major pkim over the last bunch of hundreds of years have similar questions…
7. 15:34>> of the not of the of of this very very simple unintrusive very easy right…
8. 18:09interesting is that the today the most common thing that we do for someone who dies…
9. 20:42say he's not a murderer? Now what's interesting is there's a few troubles that talk about…
10. 23:15everybody and he ended up dying from it. But essentially what you were engaging in was…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.