Getting it ready…
Know someone who would love this shiur?
Ask this shiur
Ask in your own words — the answer is the exact moment this shiur speaks to it.
What’s said in this shiur
The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shay Tahan’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.
hello sometimes a person accepts upon himself to say to elim for somebody who's sick for example for 40 days or somebody who passed away niftal and he accepts to say they live for him for a certain time and then he hears of somebody else that has a need also for the te lim zerut whether he was niftar again or whether he is sick and now the question comes does the person reciting person reciting to hilim is required to say lim a second time or maybe the first time that he says for the first sick person now that he has an intention to say also for the second one that's good enough and each one would get exactly the entire merit of his telin well that question we found in the earlier post in the maganov that says that one who says that says that one who says qaddish for one niftal is not allowed with that kadesh to be ote for another niftal rather each one should have his own kadish this root has to be entirely for each one by himself independently but many argued on that maganovam as the beretev brings from the knesset israel and also the bergatev and also the mahathir the shekel and bring that as well the bayer mushain
Jump to a moment
- 0:00hello sometimes a person accepts upon himself to say to elim for somebody who's sick for…
- 0:31person reciting to hilim is required to say lim a second time or maybe the first…
- 1:02that says that one who says qaddish for one niftal is not allowed with that kadesh…
- 1:35bring that as well the bayer mushain brings that this way as well and the duvet…
- 2:06in that topic and therefore we found to this to be a machoket those that side…
- 2:37for sure each one gets the merit needed the argument they indicate that indeed when you…
- 3:07he's also could intend his heart to be say the shaking of the mitzvah as well…
- 3:37again for the second person so then he could be mehaven in his heart he could…
Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.
More from Rabbi Shay Tahan
Har HaBayit: Where Is a Jew Allowed to Walk? The Three Machanot. Part 1Rabbi Shay Tahan · 13:22Can a Shul Vote on Shabbat? What the Halacha SaysRabbi Shay Tahan · 11:23זיוף בבחירות – מה אומרת ההלכה? | הרב שי טחן בקול ברמה עם יעקב גרודקהRabbi Shay Tahan · 8:03The Different Levels of LiarsRabbi Shay Tahan · 0:58Saying Mazal In The Diamond IndustryRabbi Shay Tahan · 1:00Campaign Promises in Halacha: Must a Candidate Keep His Word?Rabbi Shay Tahan · 17:09Which Kinds of Cooking Are a Torah Prohibition?Rabbi Shay Tahan · 2:55When You Only Have Tefilin For the 'Right' Hand.Rabbi Shay Tahan · 1:41
Get the week’s best, by email
One email a week — a handful of shiurim and music. No account needed.
Know a family who would use this? Give a Lehallel membership.