Learn How to Learn Talmud with Rabbi Ayson Englander. Brachos 26b. Written Materials Sugya 1.4

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Yisroel Roll’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We're going to start at Sugya 1.4. So, as a quick reminder that in Sugya 1.3, there was a discussion about makeups. Makeup davening's. And we had a statement, if you remember, that Reb Mari quoted ultimately Reb Yochanan who said that if a person makes a mistake and he doesn't daven Maariv, he can make it up by davening two Shacharis's. Likewise, if a person davened Shacharis missed Shacharis, excuse me, if he missed Shacharis, he can also make that up by davening two Minchas. And we said, "Okay, that's not the proper way of doing it. That's not the best way of doing it." Yes, it's true that technically that works. However, you don't get the reward for davening in the right time. You only get the reward for davening. So, there is a uh there's our davening and then there's davening at the right time. Right? When you daven at the right time, you get extra brownie points. Whereas, davening, yeah, you can daven. You can daven 24/7. You can always daven in front of Hakadosh Baruchu and you can always supplicate Hakadosh Baruchu. However, davening at the right time is better. And that's the right thing to do. That you won't have if you do this makeup kind of deal. Okay, that was in the 1.3. 1.4. Eibayahu. What does Eibayahu mean? They posed the question. Now, as I I think I mentioned in the past, Eibayahu is there are different terms used in the Gemara for questions. Some questions are like Aceve or Maceve, which the Gemara is going to bring a little later. That always implies an attack question. A challenge question. You said something and I am going to challenge that because I have a source that tell me that you are wrong. And what you said is incorrect and I'll

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00We're going to start at Sugya 1.4. So, as a quick reminder that in Sugya 1.3,…
2. 5:25And the Gemara says, "I'll tell you why." Here the Gemara is points out, as often…
3. 10:42They were up and at them before dawn over there, right? So something happened and they…
4. 16:07primary function, sure we're asking mercy. Of course. But if the primary function of prayer is…
5. 21:41which is timeless so those are the two sides to my question so again the Gemara…
6. 26:53the proper mindset you're not thinking about what's happening in your office you're not thinking about…
7. 32:11You daven Maariv twice. The ain ba zeh, and there is not in this mishum because…
8. 37:28mistakes that you cannot fix. V'chasron lo yuchal lehimanos. And something lacking, something missing, a loss,…
9. 42:52Doesn't talk about mincha. But Rebbe Yochanan had said earlier on that there was such a…
10. 48:17Yeah, I'm just confused why it won't say hasam in our case of the That's because…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.