The Age Of Chinuch For Mitzvos - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Zev Smith’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

foreign [Music] foreign [Music] this past summer someone asked me a simple question but it was a nice not simple dancer his child there was a younger child at eight nine years old who fell asleep and did not hear Abdullah matoya Shabbos is there an Indian that he should make Abdullah Sunday morning he never saw that before but then again he also missed my ear does he have to make up the marriage that he missed and as we see today we have a host of questions spanning the entire archaim questions spanning the entire archaim and some of the aradaya but basically the questions are going to come up and we have to clarify first of all when is the age of so we all know that a cotton under Bar Mitzvah as the mission says another is Perry K Michelle's essay limits with less than 13 years old there's no on a child to any of the mitzis explains this simply put he is incapable unable this simply put he is incapable unable to do mits because he's lacking the enough intelligence to perform the mitzvahs now this is the biggest side which is if someone can't do that is and as we often say every then you could do it to reverse them obviously felt that a cotton under Bar Mitzvah doesn't have enough intelligence so now we could Wonder so where did the come from the Torah says they can't be makhive and their abundant will say that's a lot of the there are bonans there are bonus heir to the Torah but I think we could do better than that let's follow mini gistro and answer one question with a different question there is

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01foreign [Music]…
2. 6:33of it but if the father is behind him supporting him and helping him so that…
3. 13:14you know that a talk did you notice that there is absolutely no Clarity in the…
4. 19:54hold maybe hell they could say later maybe the father will take him that's not a…
5. 26:03covered his head yamaka yamaka is a tremendous School of Ayers and that's why Eden start…
6. 32:18I the same quantity Rashi he's part of Krishna why is he even filler so here…
7. 38:32is on the father and the son it makes sense all of them say that there…
8. 44:48what's going to be later latest why not do it now now if you'll wait and…
9. 51:00question of course is in Europe where they European country that we might have they'd have…
10. 57:13understand where the mini is coming from the famous question of a dollar medium can you…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.