Kollel Shiur - Borer - Part 7 (a) Filters

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Avi Wiesenfeld’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Um, so I wanted to finish off with a couple of different nakudas that we didn't get to. Um, specifically talking about the sugia of filters and sieving, which is the last few sifim really. When you get from siv yud all the way down, you start to get to the sugia of the sifting and the sieving and the filtering and all of these things. So I wanted to speak a little bit about that. So a couple of nakudas in this in this in this sugia, in siv yud, so the Ramah tells us like this. The Ramah says the upper fish boy this. The Ramah says the upper fish boy ksumim dakin, hoil u'ruin lishtois bilav hachi. Right? And that's a very important uh very important Ramah that the Ramah is telling us that coming off from the Shulchan Aruch mutar lisnon b'meshmeres, so you're allowed to actually filter it. And the Ramah is telling us even though you have these ksumim, very thin ones inside, but the Ramah says you can drink it anyway. Now there's an obvious question when you learn this Ramah. And it's a very important question to ask, and the answer is even more important l'halacha answer is even more important l'halacha l'maaseh for us as well. The Tzl David asks this kasha. The Tzl David in Sifran David as well asks the question. He says, "I don't understand. The Ramah says what? So because you can drink it anyway, that makes it mutar? Slicha. We have Tosfos. We know that when you have something that you do not want, it becomes a psoles. It becomes a shailah of boy. You have an oichel in a psoles. Very nice, I could drink it, but I don't want it there. I don't want to drink it with it with it inside. And over the Tzl

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00Um, so I wanted to finish off with a couple of different nakudas that we didn't…
2. 2:04but you could drink it. So because you could drink it there are more comes along…
3. 4:35in that says the words you're allowed to do there's no problem whatsoever. Okay? So therefore…
4. 6:38Like no it can't be. It's also we always learned it's also don't cut it it's…
5. 9:11shmack. The shmeck is coming. That's what's important. Again? >> Why is it tzoiles? >> Well,…
6. 11:13beloved without this everyone would drink it. Okay, the run on that says most of the…
7. 13:48moment you're an Easternist, even if right people in Israel would drink it, but you're an…
8. 15:51need to fill the oil in. You guys are sitting and learning. Keep on sitting and…
9. 18:24you walk to the kaisel Shabbos afternoon, and you're shvitzing, you're thirsty, it's kefeil, and somebody…
10. 20:26be easier because when you pour it in it goes straight out the other side which…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.