Maseches Sanhedrin Daf 77, Daf Yomi with Rabbi Phil Karesh

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Daf Yomi with Rabbi Phil Karesh’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

good evening hope you're all doing well today we're learning not such a big blot however we are starting halfway down on we have already learned about skila and SAA and now we're going to be speaking about herg which is uh which is killing one of the three or one of the four Capital punishments the mishna B reads as follows these are the people who get killed Those Who Kill get as well as people who live in an a city that has been pined on it that it should be put to death just to remind you we did learn a couple of blot ago that there are those who hold that an has never happened because if even if there's one muza the gamar said even if there's one muza then you can't burn a muza which means you can't burn the whole place down so it could be that it never happened what level yeah but no it's true on the crime that yeah but no it's true on the crime that happened but you don't get to do an ancillary violation of in the process I'm saying why is it a lower oh I don't know you have to see in the gar I don't know the answer to that question good point uh says the what what kind of are we talking about so if somebody kills someone with a stone or with metal or or you hold someone down under the water or you hold someone in

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01good evening hope you're all doing well today we're learning not such a big blot however…
2. 4:13Rashi you have to be able to grab onto the handle in order to have the…
3. 8:25point the point is that metal has a has has a oneup over Stone some degree…
4. 12:38holding is not a murderous act but I held you in a way that you died…
5. 16:48don't so what we're saying is that by R we have regular murder we have regular…
6. 20:59the lion would have killed you no matter what whether or not you're held out peace…
7. 25:10of or no is it really the case of where would hold in a case of…
8. 29:15a somebody shot you with an arrow that was poisoned a poison tipped Arrow but you…
9. 33:23fine a person throws a rock at a wall and it bounces off the wall that's…
10. 37:34the person who was hit and killed he didn't have the opportunity to move back far…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.