Know someone who would love this shiur?
The shiur in English
The Yanuka’s own words in this shiur, translated into English by Lehallel · 871 words · 4:38. Press a time to hear it said.
0:00 There is what I just learned now in the Daf Yomi, Tractate Zevachim, page 55: it is written there that, so that eating kodshei kodashim could be permitted in the rear part of the Azarah, behind the Heichal, and also to slaughter kodashim kalim there, So there was a hatch there, there was a hatch there that was open from the outside - granted, there was a chamber, there was a hatch, an opening between the chamber, and also an opening into the Holy of Holies, into there.
0:29 From there, there is also the place where they would go in to make repairs, from above - yes. From above they would go down by chains, go down without seeing the Holy of Holies. The question there too - the question there too is whether their light was drawn from above to below. So it could be - that's it, I wrote down for myself here a few options for the lighting. In Zevachim, page 61, in Rashi - on page 61, in Rashi, it is written about the fire that came down, on the verse - from Heaven upon it: "A constant fire shall burn upon the altar; it shall not go out" - the fire that was there in the days of Moshe Rabbeinu, until Shlomo.
0:59 About 486 years this fire was there. That is, it was a fire upon the altar, a spiritual fire. So perhaps one can also say from here that there was some kind of fire, or something. Ah, that's it, that is what I said. A strong proof for your honor. What Rabbi Nosson of Breslov says. Yes, yes. That it is a source, he says there, to light up the darkness.
1:26 The Even HaShesiyah, in the sense of a precious stone, he says. Yes, A few things came out for me, really beautiful ones. Did you bring what I told your honor about Yoma, page 34, with the Chamber of Beis HaParvah - the sorcerer? Isn't that so? After all, he dug, right? He dug in order to reach the Holy of Holies. Yes. So I said: if there had been then, in his generation, in his time, even a rumor... That, your honor skipped over a little. Where, one moment? The sun, here.
1:59 The orb of the sun. The orb of the sun - no, about the Luchos it is written that they were hewn from the orb of the sun, and the Luchos were there, and he also says about the Luchos that the Even HaShesiyah was like the Luchos. So it really shines - from the orb of the sun, it is already understood that it... eh? Right. Since it is from the sun, it shines. That means it could even be that the light itself came out of the Luchos. Yes. Because it was sapphire, which was a precious stone. Sapphire, yes.
2:32 This, now, is the last thing that I saw, in Zevachim, in Zevachim, page 55, where the Gemara says to make the Azarah fit for eating kodshei kodashim, and for kodashim kalim. And also what I told the Rav, about his having dug in order to see the Holy of Holies: seemingly he would not have dug if he had known that there is darkness.
Read the whole shiur in English (4 more parts)
3:00 That means we have to say of him that it went so far that they knew, apparently. After all, if he were digging for himself in order to reach a place of darkness and gloom, he would not have done that. And I also said, perhaps there was light from above too... So that strengthens what the Rav says, what we said, that is, that seemingly, what I said at the beginning, that there was a precious stone, there was a precious stone that shone, and the Luchos which were of sapphire, which was a precious stone that shone. And then the Yerushalmi in Yoma, chapter 5, halachah 2, where the Yerushalmi says...
3:35 On the question - this is really, this Yerushalmi is... a real support. Because it says that it was by the light of the Ark. But what is there in the Ark? The precious stone that shines. That is, the light broke forth from it; that is what shone from there. So that supports your honor. Baruch Hashem. The difficulty is settled. Yes? Baruch Hashem. That's it, we have finished this question. This question has been settled beautifully. So one moment, we said this Yerushalmi. Yerushalmi Yoma, chapter 5, halachah 2.
4:02 Chapter 5, halachah 2. It comes out from here that it was by the light of the Ark. "A tzohar you shall make for the ark" - that is a precious stone, according to all of them a precious stone, it is a precious stone - and the Luchos were of precious stone, they were inside the Ark, so it is as I resolved it for your honor. And also the second thing, that the sorcerer - Yoma, page 34, again - that presumably there was light, that is, he would not have dug to get there if there were no light there.
4:32 That is how it seemed to me. Whatever seems right in your honor's eyes. Thank you.
Ask this shiur
Ask in your own words — the answer is the exact moment this shiur speaks to it.
What’s said in this shiur
The opening of this shiur, in The Yanuka — Rav Shlomo Yehuda’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.
א יש א עכשיו למדנו דח יוני מסכת זמחים ה צחו שמה שבשביל שאפשר יהיה להתיר אכילה של קודשי קודשים בחלק החורי של העזהרה מאחורי וגם לשחוט שמה חודשים קלים אז היה שמה לול שם לול שהיה פתוח מה מבחוץ אמם היו היה תא היה לול פתח בן התא וגם פתח לתוך קודש קודשים ושמה אז בסוף מקום שהיו הולכים קודשים ושמה אז בסוף מקום שהיו הולכים לתקן >> מלמעלה >> מלמעלה היו יורדים בשלשלות יורדים ולא רואים את כלש חודשים גם משמה >> השאלה גם משמה הם היו אז אם האור אז האור שלמה נמשך מלמעלה למטה >> אז יכול להיות זהו אני כתבתי לי פה כמה אופציות של תאורה >> בזבחין בדף סא >> בדף סא בר ורשי כתוב על האש שירדה לה פסכטר שמים עליה >> האש תמיד תוקד על המזבח לא תרא באש שהי הייתה בימי משה רבנו עד שלמה 486 שנה בערך אש הזאת הייתה זאת אומרת 486 שנה בערך אש הזאת הייתה זאת אומרת הייתה אש על גבי המזבח אש רוחנית אז אולי גם אפשר להגיד מפה שהיה איזה סוג של איזה אש או איזה משהו אה זהו זה מה שאמרתי לראיה לחזקה לכבדו >> מה שרבי נתן בן בונזל אומר >> כן כן שזה מקור הוא אומר שמה ש חו להעיר את החושך כותב >> אבן השתייה זה בחינת האבן טוב כן >> זה כמה דברים יצאו לרבוע ממש יפים
Jump to a moment
- 0:00א יש א עכשיו למדנו דח יוני מסכת זמחים ה צחו שמה שבשביל שאפשר יהיה להתיר…
- 0:31קודשים ושמה אז בסוף מקום שהיו הולכים לתקן >> מלמעלה >> מלמעלה היו יורדים בשלשלות יורדים…
- 1:03486 שנה בערך אש הזאת הייתה זאת אומרת הייתה אש על גבי המזבח אש רוחנית אז…
- 1:37>> הבאת את מה שאמרתי לכבודו על יומה דף לד עם א עם הבשקת בית החרבה…
- 2:08>> והלוחות היו שמה וגם הוא אומר הלוחות שאבן שתייה זה כמו היה הלוחות >> אז…
- 2:38>> בדברים דף נו שהוא אמר ש ל >> ולהכשיר את הזרה להחלף קודש קודשים קודשים…
- 3:10למקום חשה פעלה הוא לא היה עושה את זה >> לא יכול להיות שכשהוא חכה הוא…
- 3:40ארון >> אבל מה יש בארון האבן טוב שמאיר זאת אומרת זה היה בוקר את האור…
- 4:10>> יפה מאוד ברוך השם >> הצור תעשה לתיבה זה אבן טוב שומרים כל שמרים אבן…
Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.
Get the week’s best, by email
One email a week — a handful of shiurim and music. No account needed.
Know a family who would use this? Give a Lehallel membership.