Pesachim 16a: The Unique View of Reb Elazar That Liquids Always Remain Pure

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi YY Jacobson’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

the yeshiva dotnet okay tidy Eden tessai Annamma Aleph one two three four five five lines from the top the Gemara quoted a price and the bracer brought three opinions about the biblical status of beverages in terms of Toma opinion number one was Ramaiya it Toma opinion number one was Ramaiya it mayor said liquid can become Tommy min hot area doesn't the POSIX a in parish mini that a food or liquids fall in to a Kayleigh that has become Tommy from a share its meaning the Kaylee was a resigned the liquid can become Tommy but Ramaiya said biblically that liquid cannot transfer tumor to anything and anybody not even other foods that liquid will not transfer Toma practically speaking it means that if there's a speaking it means that if there's a Suffolk if a transfer Toma we assume the lenient perspective meaning that the other thing is Tarkas it's a rabbinic doubt because only rabbinical II can liquid transfer Toma but if there's a Suffolk if the liquid itself became Tom a then we choose the stringent path because it's a sway Coeur de rice then they Commissioner Bratton continued their beer laws are agreed with rib mayor but Shane no you're a rebel army could work then there was the second could work then there was the second opinion other extreme W Hooda who says not only can liquid become Tommy but liquid can transfer Toma and not only to food even to vessels I'll show you sha sir but Coakley you tomorrow even a Kaylee can become Tom a from Moscone unique judicial review hoodie that a Kaylee can be a Shana me their eyes and then there was the middle opinion regulation of Shimon who say that Mashka liquid can become Tommy minute IRA it can transfer it biblically

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00the yeshiva dotnet okay tidy Eden tessai Annamma Aleph one two three four five five lines…
2. 4:34an trimmer but by Katja Mia so in this case would become Tommy ravine in the…
3. 9:44so Sarah hey Joseph Benny as each trade there's a testimony that we have from Yosef…
4. 14:22then I could say I made it only here I didn't make it here and there…
5. 19:33could bring on shoppers for example the carbon comment slaughtering a lamb is forbidden on Shabbos…
6. 24:43drove with both of his statements not with one statement for ID and another problem Mohabbatein…
7. 29:20the mask endow a regular March didn't imagine basement Pattaya Lloyd Gaza and the liquids of…
8. 34:23of a carbon touches any Tom a you cannot eat it you cannot eat it uh-uh-uh…
9. 39:00when he said Mashka basement pacaya story to transfer it's not car bonus it's : but…
10. 44:10touches our Kaylee touches a person touches the food but if it touches a ravie or…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.