Machine Matzoh An Explosive Halachic Debate Repost 04 01 2025

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Yoel Plutchok’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Okay. So, we're going to talk today about mash matzah, but uh we need a a few few introductions to the topic before we start. So, first of all, introduction number one and I think this is the most important introduction is that uh this is a little different than some of the other controversies that we've talked about and as in in in this way as follows. A lot of the other controversies have been small-time controversies have been small-time people who tried to make innovations and were met with resistance by the gelar who spoke strongly against them. And uh we know we know how that shakes out. What's in about this mikas is that on both sides is truly truly geladar the the biggest of the big and they the the fight became extremely heated and they spoke very passionately and personally about each other and as we're going to read the truis and read their own words I just want I want to that that's the I just want I want to that that's the first to keep in mind is that the people on both sides that were talking about the the of the generation okay so so as follows originally The way matzah was baked was in every person's personal home before the suda a person and his wife would get together and they'd bake bread. They'd have matzah for the suda like that. The days brings a has a few interpretations of what the

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00Okay. So, we're going to talk today about mash matzah, but uh we need a a…
2. 6:09don't know. Maybe it gets quicker or slower. Maybe it's too hard to knead it properly.…
3. 12:26could take out all these and in the in the matzab baker were not behaving and…
4. 18:34and for many many grace. So where does the fight start? The fight starts when it…
5. 24:44on on a on a much much higher level. So now okay so now let's let's…
6. 30:55galitia. That was given by French rabbanim by German rabanim with a very wide nobody there…
7. 37:03gets rolled out of here, 25% of it is not usable for batch number one for…
8. 43:13debate you don't talk about this It's because I say so and I'm not giving a…
9. 49:23it's help because just just like if a cotton's doing it and that doesn't count. So…
10. 55:31that I'm a kaldas and I'm I'm I'm make and I don't know how to learn…

Every second of this shiur plays inside FilteredTube — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.