Confusion, Crying, & Consolation: A Historio-Linguistic Lesson for Tisha B'Av

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Reuven Chaim Klein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

reality um before I start I was thinking you know just to get everybody in the mood you know on the count of three on the count of three we're all going to enter a state of aus and start crying and thinking about the Bas and just go right into it okay on the count of three one 3 didn't work I see it's not working everyone's just I see it's not working everyone's just smiling you can't just you can't just jump right into Thea you have to think about it you have to realize what's happening you know why why why are we in aist what are we crying about what does it even mean to cry so beem in this in this talk I'm going to do three things first of all I'm going to try to Define these Concepts what's going on in Tish just P it simply defining the terms so and then we're going to explain the significance we're going to explain the significance of it and then at the end we'll have some different about uh a way of looking towards the future says there of crying we'll get to the part at the end but what what exactly is di what exactly is what exactly is AOS so as I was saying before when you talk about these type of things it's sometimes very helpful to just very clearly Define what these terms are and when you have a clear definition of what the word simply means and maybe the atmology of the word how it relates to similar words then you have a clear understanding of what what's the concept that these words represent so we're going to try to

Jump to a moment

1. 0:31reality um before I start I was thinking you know just to get everybody in the…
2. 6:15out drip drip different times at different stages so it's drip drip so that's why truma…
3. 12:26eight meaning mixed up means thatu was in his his mind was in a in a…
4. 18:38nothing and I look out the window I look out the window to see in the…
5. 24:47mother of the you have the you have the people who are crying like what are…
6. 30:55confusion and the other set of words that come out of B lamid is what we…
7. 37:18on you know his FAL y before no it doesn't say like that it just says…
8. 43:34mentioned in t but other than that no one ever heard of it it wasn't worshiped…
9. 49:38and they and they experienced hasem firsthand in so many different ways with with the with…
10. 55:54didn't but today we read that was going to destroy because of the OS what does…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.