Makos Daf 16

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Moshe Meir Weiss’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Kazan. We are holding and we are holding four lines from the bottom. Remember we said that was of the opinion that you could give a even though it is only a doubt it's not certain that he will get punished and says that we don't give suffic we don't give it a conditional well if this happens you'll get mus we don't do Now, who would be silly enough to swear? Uh, Marshall. He says, "I swear that I will eat this Frankfurter bun today." And the day passes, it's already and he didn't eat the frank for the bun, which is in incredible, but he didn't eat the frank for the bun. Uh are on the same page both say that he doesn't get malus but they say it for different reasons. You know why? There's no action. It's only speech. For speech there's no malus. Remember, it has to be similar to the to the love of musling an animal. It has to be an action. Speech, even though he has a big mouth, but it's not an action. It's not an action. And if there's no action ain't like a lot because at any time let's say Marshall says he's up early 6 in the morning he says I swear that I'm going to eat this Frankfurt bun today. So the Adam give him a warning that you know if you don't eat it now

Jump to a moment

1. 0:39Kazan. We are holding and we are holding four lines from the bottom. Remember we said…
2. 5:15was la because by leaving it over you're not doing anything. By leaving it over is…
3. 9:45oh or he curses them both at the same time. So the tanakama says that even…
4. 14:11since we don't know which one is the real father and that's suffic well you're right…
5. 18:43so if you take the mother from the children. There is no way to reform this.…
6. 23:06else. And since you accepted marriage for her from someone else, then you can't take her…
7. 27:29of you only give one punishment since you pay you're not going to get malus like…
8. 31:46aim? Even if you make the you can't enol it if you're enoling it for an…
9. 36:09centipede and then so to simplify things if you eat something that creeps on the land…
10. 40:41also now once we're talking about lysaku. There's another application of lysaku and that's holding in…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.