CHAZARAH - Chullin Daf 21 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Eli Stefansky’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

[music] >> A good and healthy Yom Tov boys and girls. We finished eating and we are sitting with Mordechai and all the smart people here. We see that came in for Yom Tov. We are holding Omer Avino. We're talking about every bird, every animal, every human being has two pipes. Very interesting pipes. They're made very similarly. They look like air conditioning pipes. One of them at least. That's the breathing pipe called the trachea. The other one is the esophagus that the The other one is the esophagus that the food goes down. What happens if one of the pipes becomes dislocated? What happens to the animal? The animal basically becomes a treif, becomes dislocated. It'll look something like this. Dislocated. Then he comes with a knife and performs shchita. So what happens if the trachea - it almost looks the same. Look at that. The trachea pops out on the bird. And you did shchita. And you did shchita. So the Gemara says it depends. Omer Avino Omer Lee Robin Barkisi told me by Yechezkel in Eiger Siman that when it happens in a bird it doesn't matter cuz by a bird anyway all you need to do is shecht one siman. L'Omer Elo ben Melika. When you use your finger, you're in the Beit Hamikdash and you're going through the back of the neck of the bird. So if you find out that the trachea was was was dislocated before you started

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01[music] >> A good and healthy Yom Tov boys and girls. We finished eating and we…
2. 2:36Says the Gemara Rabbi Yirmeya bar Shmuel, kol hakosher bishchita Where's my bird? Oh. >> [snorts]…
3. 5:43a kosher bird does not emit to a month right away unless you swallow should we…
4. 8:47You're going downwards with the knife. Down. I should really I don't want to mess up…
5. 11:53anything here. I don't know why. Oh oh oh it's dead? Too late. I just shach…
6. 14:57by the way, is uh you'll be surprised to see the size of it, and then…
7. 18:13of them completely or or not completely. >> [clears throat] >> arrive most It makes no…
8. 21:19so if you do that to a human being, obviously we're not going to show a…
9. 24:25is a machlokes here or no machlokes. Are you saying that it's like uh that you…
10. 27:32should Anything above the minimum, yeah. Yes, anything above the minimum. Correct. Good point. Yes. So,…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.