An Earth Shattering Thematic Approach To the 10 Martys and The Kinnus

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

well i understand why we say it on yom kippur the gemara says miriam so you understand why we talk about the death of the righteous on yom kippur the death of the righteous atonement but why talk about the asura malchus on tish above and the symbol shot is based on rosh hashanah the death of the righteous i like the burning of the temple but the question is many righteous people have been slain throughout the ages why do we specifically refer to the asara haruki mahas and the following approach occurred to me based on something i saw in the commentary of the nasivas hamish but namely the nasibu says that he wrote an approach on icha not to explain jewish tragedy because there's nothing redeeming inherently of just commemorating jewish tragedy we have better things to do with our time than to sit on the floor and mourn and commemorate jewish jewish tragedy the purpose of commemorating jewish tragedy is to be able to identify what caused the jewish tragedy and be able to weed it out and improve it and not do it again and therefore perhaps this would also explain the and and this would be a new approach to answer of salvation's question if salvation writes i don't know why there's no kinna to commemorate the khameninski pogroms sound humbly suggests and in the past we offered an answer from rab maisha because the khamenski pagrams were not related to the samiktas only tragedy that comes as that's perpetrated by the reigning government is commemorated on tisha because only that is something connected to the corbin when the tragedy is caused by the

Jump to a moment

1. 0:32well i understand why we say it on yom kippur the gemara says miriam so you…
2. 1:03hashanah the death of the righteous i like the burning of the temple but the question…
3. 1:37there's nothing redeeming inherently of just commemorating jewish tragedy we have better things to do with…
4. 2:41prevailing powers so then the romans destroyed the base of makdash they took over our kayak…
5. 3:11but now i want to focus on arsene wennin and let us suggest that the reason…
6. 4:12adai in maracaybanu still prevalent they still reverberate we're still committing the same sins so when…
7. 4:42tenshwatim soldisef in other words their sin was safe when what day of the year could…
8. 5:13prevalent look at its repercussions look at how it reverberates that's paid the price for machiave…
9. 6:15and they said you stay there and you go up to your big jerusalem we'll stay…
10. 6:46the kinos the same thematic approach applies to the burning of the shots why are we…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.