The Hidden Depths of the Passover Haggadah - Part 2 - Rabbi Dr. David Gottlieb

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Hidabroot - Torah & Judaism’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we got halfway through the second half of the paragraph is a repetition of the first step with certain changes i'm not going to go through that long long story I'm going to cut go to the closing of the of the paragraph it ends not usually when it's not Chavez it ends baraha Tasha Moqaddas robbaz bombing that sanctifies the Jewish people and the holidays here the single word for holidays is the times as you know if it were an ordinary showers which is not a holiday then it would just say makati Josh shabbos sanctify the Chavez now that this year it's going to be both shabbos and the holiday you have the full ending makadi SH a shabbos you throw last money the obvious question is why do we have Israel only on the harveys why don't we have Israel on shabbos also i mean that's right and then if you're going to have somehow shabbos and smiling together and you going to put the both in which that seems reasonable who dictated the order yeah it wasn't the colonel nothing wrong but wasn't shabbos like one of the first i shall create javis like right after he created man like so that was way before any hobbies is waiting for Israel so in correlation okay so if you want to think about it historically makes perfect tense first came shabbos movie independently of the Jewish people and other holidays came after the Jewish people were established so you could say it's just chronological I think you could say that yeah ok that's the deeper point here the point here is absolutely fundamental difference between Chavez and holidays

Jump to a moment

1. 0:17we got halfway through the second half of the paragraph is a repetition of the first…
2. 4:29independently of witnesses all together and that being the case when we say the beginning of…
3. 8:38that the prophets established that on the seventh day of circus you bring willow branches and…
4. 12:50it it's a fascinating process people talk about the 18-minute matters that's really speaking not true…
5. 16:56referred to before coldest clean yes a vehicle anybody who's impoverished it's having trouble raising food…
6. 21:43sons okay so the goal of illness says number four here symbolizes the matriarch ah because…
7. 25:50very very powerful idea I wanted to ask how this before women relate to these percussion…
8. 29:53happening and he's wondering why are these things happen and he's asking about these things to…
9. 34:01step that says this ought to be an answer the question right I've bought in vain…
10. 38:21symbols of freedom how does it work together and I want you to know that in…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.