Can Only a Shomer Shabbos Soldier or Doctor Desecrate Shabbos to Save a Life?

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

guard to to do his work to to uh to take a position to go in a tank on chabas and he could switch positions with someone who is not a sh shabas is it permitted for him to so to speak put the shabas on a different Jew is it a violation of causing someone else to sin or likewise if you're a doctor in the hospital and you're assigned the shab shift there's another secular Doctor Who's assigned the Thursday shift and you want to switch is this considered a VI ation of you're basically causing someone else of you're basically causing someone else to sin or do we say you're not causing anyone to sin because anyway they would be allowed to work on chabas they're working to save someone's life so anyway it's that's one question another question is if you're a patient is there a preference if you need medical treatment life-saving treatment is there a preference to go to a secular Doctor Who and anyway he's going to be M shabas or is there a preference to go to a Jewish doctor now preference to go to a Jewish doctor now what would the preference be to go to a Jewish doctor the preference would be that based on the idea of we know there's a concept that if you have an extenuating circumstance so the Torah allows you to violate the sin based on the premise that when you're forced to do something it's not considered like you're doing it it begins with um the lum but once we're talking about the topic of soldiers switching

Jump to a moment

1. 0:33guard to to do his work to to uh to take a position to go in…
2. 4:12came over in his Jeep and gave handed me a telegram that I should send it…
3. 7:53outside of Earth Israel that is the contributing factor to why they don't have children okay…
4. 11:29is so if I put this m shabas in my post am I causing him to…
5. 15:09it is aah for a God-fearing Doctor Who who ill who sick patients come to him…
6. 18:51chabas if you normally keep chabas you're allowed to desecrate chabas to Save a Life if…
7. 22:32secular doctor he's not only doing it for the paycheck I mean it's safe to assume…
8. 26:10you that supersedes Jewish life so you're causing him to sin okay that's sh um says…
9. 29:50also disturbing you're ruining their of shabas but the secular doctor he's already on his own…
10. 33:26your job toas okay so back to the hospital case is it violation of to give…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.