Daf Hashavua - Nedarim 76a

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

progress. Okay, I get to my it everyone. We're continuing in Nedarim. Tonight we do 16 b. Amud aleph. So, the Gemara on 15 a had a shaila. >> [snorts] >> The Mishnah said that if you are make him in advance, it's ineffective. What if you're mayfer in advance? Rebbi Eliezer says it works. The chachamim say it doesn't work. Rebbi Eliezer advanced the following kal vachomer. If you could be mayfer a neder that already chal, that are chamer, certainly should be able to mayfer a neder that weren't chal yet. That's assuming that when something is chal, it's stronger than before something is chal. The chachamim basically said no. We agree with you fundamentally in the logic that when something is chal, it's stronger than before it's chal. However, the chachamim said the chachamim said that we have a gezeiras hakasuv of isha yakimenu isha yafeirenu. Since you can't be make him, you can't be mayfer. The Gemara on 15 a had a shaila that according to Rebbi Eliezer who says you could be mayfer in advance, the shaila is is it chal and then bottle? Or is it not chal at and then bottle? Or is it not chal at all? Right? That was the shaila. Is it chal and then is bottle or is it not chal at all? So, Gemara brought different rayos in different directions. And the last tushma the Gemara said as follows. The Gemara said that the chachamim said to Rebbi Eliezer that if a mikvah which transforms someone from tumah to taharah but does not prevent someone from becoming tamei, so we see it's easier to

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00progress. Okay, I get to my it everyone. We're continuing in Nedarim. Tonight we do 16…
2. 2:06tamei, so we see it's easier to be metahir something that was already chal than to…
3. 4:40So, the whole argument of the chachamim is saying that you're able to prevent prevent it…
4. 6:43prevent and we see from mikvah it's not easier to prevent. Mhm. What do you mean…
5. 9:17becomes tahar. Not that you're going to prevent it from becoming tamei because how would that…
6. 11:49to him. We're not sure what you hold we're not sure if you mean you could…
7. 13:55given she's run but a tire and if you plant it in the ground they're tar.…
8. 16:28key a little bit of a cover home and key high govna mean a you made…
9. 18:31before she goes free when she becomes an hour certainly when she is an hour you…
10. 21:21right. Fundamentally, Rebbe Elazar the Chachamim would darshan this kal vachomer. But You say you can…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.