Maseches Makkos Daf 20, Daf Yomi with Rabbi Phil Karesh

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Daf Yomi with Rabbi Phil Karesh’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Good evening. I hope you're all doing well. Today we're learning and we're starting about 12 lines from the bottom of the testament three lines before the wide lines and there was a question that was being posed in the base. A person is at the entrance to what's in regards to my shi the redeeming should happen outside not inside. What should we do? So it says the garb of now what's obvious is as follows that if he is outside and his backpack is inside the isos are and the is he can no longer redeem all the redeeming is done outside of then you bring it in but you can't do the redeeming inside. What if what if it's reversed he's standing inside the threshold of your and his backpack is outside. So here we have a draw. There was an older gentleman who was sitting in the back of the basement and he quotes the and your completeness. What does this mean? He holds that both you and your bag have to be in the same place. And therefore if any part of you is inside, even if some part of you is outside, you can no longer redeem. Ma can only be redeemed outside. Papa. Let's say that a person's holding a stick and the stick has at the end of its bag. It has the uh that which he wants to redeem. So take we don't know if that's would be different than a bag. Would it be the same as a bag? That part

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01Good evening. I hope you're all doing well. Today we're learning and we're starting about 12…
2. 3:53do that that's not a problem he can eat it there's only one problem turning to…
3. 8:13So is when the fruits were they were and they were brought into says they have…
4. 12:32there's a tension between and raa as to whether or not this actually is a teu.…
5. 16:21who's doing it really separate separate problem nothing to do with this Mishna same just sacos…
6. 20:44not he had one so if you have one how can you have if it would…
7. 25:07saying which finger by my ring finger I was so I picked up my ring finger.…
8. 28:47boom, two hairs come out after a mace dies. If you're doing it because your of…
9. 32:53they cut their uh they have no beard and they cut their sideburn to be aligned…
10. 37:12You're not cutting. That's probably seems to be a bit. Yeah, I have no idea. Anyways,…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.