Audio Yerushalmi Bava Kamma (Vilna) 7-8

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Yosef Gavriel Bechhofer’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we're how does a work isan whatever breaks as it is walking M to walk in the normal fashion to break however was kicking or Pebbles are sprinting out from underneath its feet those Pebbles bre or it by kicking or the Pebbles which spew up on feet feet break only half is paid if the animal stepped on a trod on a um vessel and breaks it and the broken pieces for another CLE and they break the second CLE the first one you pay full damages last one you pay only half damages okay so the one which is direct full damages one which is indirect half damages now it's not grma grma because you causes Pebbles to FL fly right that's I should say you didn't just cause the Pebbles to fly the Pebbles flew as a result of your activity grandma is only where you have not caused directly anything to happen you caused indirectly things to happen classic case being although I don't know if it's necessarily true class case mean you in case where you open left a door to a field open in front of a cow so the C enders in there you caed it you didn't actually uh have any direct impact but where you cause Pebbles to fly it's not just you're causing that it's your direct impact of your activities okay you see the difference between the two so Tauros is direct impact of your activities even though

Jump to a moment

1. 0:11we're how does a work isan whatever breaks as it is walking M to walk in…
2. 5:40Ros which is the way the Pama should travel because no Pebbles and uh no Pebbles…
3. 11:01said you have to pay okay so another point to make is that the wants to…
4. 16:44indirectly the what I remember that distinction somewhere [Music] I'm later on speak what's sh what's…
5. 22:09AR I'm not sure I I don't know does it say what is it sign can…
6. 27:27vases to tail and make things uh break okay says next now Chang out the first…
7. 33:10K or after which case have the parameters of what paramet should it have right so…
8. 39:40neveress okay that's whether so it's not like a classic a classic of the Toros themselves…
9. 45:26it's the object itself which broke just had to jump over there in order to break…
10. 50:41really an indect yeah I think the B actually speaks about that but I might mistaken…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.