It Wouldn't Be Purim Without Rav Yonasan Eibeshutz - Illuminating Why there are 2 Days of Purim

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

uniform way that everybody celebrates the same day so in other words pesach is the 15th day of nisan it doesn't matter where you live what surrounds your city where your city is located everyone's celebrating the same calendar date and it's the same thing for every single yamtif with the exception of purim perm is the the one exception where depending on what kind of city you live in you would celebrate a different day so you know the open cities the farm celebrate the 14th and the kraken the kraken celebrate the 15th and the ramban it's kadai to the 15th and the ramban it's kadai to see this ramban inside i didn't put the whole thing on the sheath it's the first round about himself and he asks uh pretty poetically based on the sukim of the mcgill he says right that's obviously a paraphrase of apostate in the magilla so in other words his first question is you know why are khazal uh inspiring uh disparity and inspiring uh a fragmentation why would you have some fragmentation why would you have some people celebrate one day and sell the celebrate the other day in other words uh there's a there's a clown in the turtle this actually it's apostle to do and one of the remove them is says technically it's not a uh it's not going to be a direct siddique a violation of latest guidedo because it's like two different bhattay dinam in two different cities so if you have one better than one say one better than the other city city a could follow its as in and city b could follow its best then

Jump to a moment

1. 0:31uniform way that everybody celebrates the same day so in other words pesach is the 15th…
2. 3:10when the rabbis make enactments they follow the the paradigm of the torah we don't find…
3. 5:45i can't say for sure i think robianas and ibishits says that mordechai was a gilgal…
4. 9:02shabbos that's a a question that the reshening deal with the rush and tysus so the…
5. 11:45first but then would he be saying that he lived 120 full years that's another question…
6. 14:54but as a spiritual entity he died arab shabbos when did he write the thirteenth suffrage…
7. 17:30there is a befitterish membership that even though he designated which people are going to live…
8. 20:23so moshe's available concluded twice for those who value his nashamah it concluded on your gimbal…
9. 23:23says he oh he can asked he cannot sullivan ezra put a cosmic that live don't…
10. 26:00say why not why would they celebrate very parshat because what were they celebrating the fact…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.