Amud Yomi Masechet Shabbat Daf 123A

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Dovid Hofstedter’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

[Music] the second line from the top we learned in the mishna that the says it's m to take a corn and you're allowed to take a hammer to crack nuts with it Raba learned that that means even if it's a even if it's a hammer of a blacksmith a blacksmith Hammer which is M which Hammer which is M which is but here if you're using it for you want to use the hammer itself to crack nuts it's motor if your purpose is not to move the hammer to remove it from s you want to use the hammer for permitted use to crack the nuts it's m therefore he holds a following says it says a morar it says a mortar is something where usually Crush something then the garlic so if you have a m mortar which is used to crush garlic now the is a you usually use it for grinding for which is a if it has garlic in it you can be metal AAL but if it doesn't have garlic metal AAL but if it doesn't have garlic in it you can't be metal so don't we see that the and it's only M because it has the shum in it because it has garlic in it which the garlic itself is something which is not M but it's only M because it has it has the shum it has the garlic otherwise you would say that it's a that it's m so don't you see from here that is is M even if it's a it's it's

Jump to a moment

1. 0:02[Music] the second line from the top we learned in the mishna that the says it's…
2. 2:44it can only and therefore and that obviously is also on shab so it's m you…
3. 5:16it if you keep the meat in it so it's also used for storage so the…
4. 7:53M wanted to thought to answer like we did before this going according to that but…
5. 10:30now have any other item on the Hammer that might now distort and ruin the the…
6. 13:04no he says that even if it's not part of it is exposed you can stick…
7. 15:40even if you're not being the M directly you're doing it indirectly how can tell why…
8. 18:15here we don't say that it's [Music] AOS said that you can be a needle to…
9. 20:55me what's the comparison between the two by we have by it says by talks when…
10. 23:34because it has a use because sometimes a person he won't put the eye into the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.