The Hidden Depths of the Passover Haggadah - Part 3 - Rabbi Dr. David Gottlieb

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Hidabroot - Torah & Judaism’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

you started the paragraph right after the four questions I what am I you know I pointed out yesterday that the first two sentences in this paragraph contradict one another the first one says we were slaves to Pharaoh next one says if a sham but not taken our ancestors out then we would have been but the truth is then we would have been but the truth is took our ancestors out so we weren't so we said when you say we you could either mean the people sitting at this table and while our contemporaries or it can mean the nation and in the first sentence says we were slaves it means the nation second sense is talking about us as individuals of course you and I weren't their ancestors were there but later on I gotta it says everyone is responsible to look at himself as if he went out we'll talk about that when we get there I think I want a comment on is the second sentence says if I share the second sentence says if I share without taking our ancestors out of Egypt we and our children our grandchildren would have been God he uses an important word miss sure the new Shuba demon the Pharaoh in Egypt the first sentence says I Vadim good less secretary says my shoe of adding that had the same word ever is a slave mishu abad means that you are beholden to your under the other person's influence or are you owe something to the other

Jump to a moment

1. 0:14you started the paragraph right after the four questions I what am I you know I…
2. 4:18that was largely displaced by the fact it away i sheltered us out there ok now…
3. 8:23what startling fanciful oh that's the point about evidence means a slave be sure about means…
4. 12:26get in the world attention you get the more famous you are and sever the zone…
5. 16:32that wasn't there before but you include night Anna we include the time of the machine…
6. 20:39help you it can't say at the time of the Messiah so we are using it…
7. 25:21who's absolutely distant can't say you Barack Obama thank God because to say you Barack Obama…
8. 29:35she I'll come back okay alright so that's three questions so far now the there's another…
9. 33:42and he believes foolish things but he's not a hundred percent self-confident he realizes that there…
10. 37:53concept though why son is open and the wicked son is closed mmm direct diametric opposite…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.