CHAZARAH - Chullin Daf 75 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Eli Stefansky’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

[music] Good morning. When we have So you have a donkey and you redeemed the donkey with a sheep. But what if the sheep was found inside a mother who was are you allowed to use that for? Now obviously we're talking about a benua that's worth how much? Less or more than the donkey? >> Less. must be less because [clears throat] if it's worth more then there's no question I can use tissues I can use potatoes anything does this have of a of a of a sheep [clears throat] holds that a fullterm fetus that was born that that he found a bakqua requires a it's not considered a benua It's not even a question since it requires so it's a regular sheep. So you could do it, you could use it as a but where's the question according to that say that even a full-term fetus is considered a benu. Let's just consider it like a bunch of meat packaged up ready to go. It's in a pot. You can't use chopped meat for and that's what it is. Yes, it's walking around, but it's edible meat. It's not packaged meat. It's running around. It's jumping. So, this is a regular sheep. Why? Why do you say that you can't use it? You're learning from the what? It says in the by it must be born. There's another that we're going to learn today. But it has to be born. It can't be ceserian. So what this animal this was it born? No. So you can't use it and you learn from that you can't use it. But if you're going to learn from PES, so let's make a complete comparison. The to know that a P must be a male without has to be less than a year. So to buy says, you're right. But there's a special that you could use even something that

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01[music] Good morning. When we have So you have a donkey and you redeemed the donkey…
2. 2:59you can't use it and you learn from that you can't use it. But if you're…
3. 5:38You don't. In other words, it's they're both they're both the same. Says the two separate…
4. 8:54What's the problem? He already had through the blood of the mother says we're talking about…
5. 11:29if you toss them back into the water, I'm not a big fisherman, but you know,…
6. 14:41you get cars you don't get cars you get malus at the end of the day…
7. 17:21an animal. So that's why I need a to say it's an animal. So why you…
8. 20:01maybe you could eat the mother or maybe not. Maybe they're if the if the doesn't…
9. 23:22He didn't die afterwards. He was dead to begin with. But you are telling me a…
10. 26:04according to once the animal this baby puts his feet down on the ground it's all…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.