Parshas Vayechi: A Rebuttal on Behalf of the Chashmonaim

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

present a new approach one approach we're all familiar with it's the dissenting view that we're not so familiar with on the possibility literally the rod will not be removed from and the staff of law giving me Bane ragla from between his legs until Sheila comes and to him is the Gathering of Nations and their various perusem in the who dominate Claude Israel the Macho cake refers to the descendants of Hillel who teach Toyo barabim the tiger mushami says there will always be malachim there'll always be lame de Tyra and so forth let us Begin by seeing the rambanda ramban's commentary on this pasok is somewhat well known thank you but it's the dissenting view which is not as well known says when the plastic says the rod will not be removed from Yehuda it does not mean it will not be removed forever because there's another passage Hashem is going to take you and your king so it can't mean you'll always have Kings not always there will be times that the king is exiled so so it can mean there always will be king Swami Huda because the Kings will go on together when the Kings and golos he's not an acting King and there's another possible now paraphrases the Posse the past success Royal there were many days there was no King so how could it mean there will always be a king from Yehuda there were many days there was no King at all what is the navi saying is the navi

Jump to a moment

1. 0:31present a new approach one approach we're all familiar with it's the dissenting view that we're…
2. 6:09so we have over here just look very quickly in number 11 from the safer some…
3. 11:53oh and we're gonna do it and and many we shine and give different terrorists into…
4. 17:31have by side one of the most famous comments in all the writings of the ramban…
5. 23:26for his own personal honor but the way it's set over the various various of this…
6. 29:05this is Iran you need to learn your history says Iran would anyone here asks but…
7. 34:15that the plastic says in small base Park Zion is and it's calling the shifden people…
8. 40:09to this answer who does bottle who does battle that doesn't make any sense this logic…
9. 45:55Milan Day Torah but the leader of the Jewish religion is that look in the about…
10. 52:17and abarinet was the preeminent leader of the Jewish people chief minister the end of the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.