Sefer Shaf Ve'yativ: The Tenth Man in a Minyan

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shay Tahan’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

the tenth men in the minion many minyanim have exactly enough people to form a minion ten men sometimes if a person doesn't come the mignon breaks down a minyan which relies on such ten men and one agrees to attend one of those minyanim may back out of it if it becomes inconvenient for him to go anyone who had tried to arrange a temporary minion understands the difficulties that face the organizer one quickly learns that it is necessary to secure pledge of attendance from more than the minimum 10 men necessary either that or face almost certain delay and ultimately the dissolution of the mignon if one said that he'll come to the minion he committed what is the obligation of one who commits to joins sacha mignon the better self quotes her god maimoni who discusses the case of town with only ten men living there with rosh hashanah approaching one of the men wishes to travel to a different town for the upcoming young season the god maimoni ruled that the town may force the man to stay unless he hires someone else to take his place in dominion adds that a town with 11 men living in it does not have this restriction any single one may travel and we are not concerned that one of the remaining ten will be unable to make it to the minion this is also the ruling of the kapha heim this is brought down in sofsiman nunhei the ruling of the shuhanaru appears to be very strange very odd after all how can you be so certain that nothing will happen to jeopardize the mignon at the last minute if there's exactly 10 men what are the odds

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01the tenth men in the minion many minyanim have exactly enough people to form a minion…
2. 0:32anyone who had tried to arrange a temporary minion understands the difficulties that face the organizer…
3. 1:04quotes her god maimoni who discusses the case of town with only ten men living there…
4. 1:35may travel and we are not concerned that one of the remaining ten will be unable…
5. 2:06that all will make it to the prayer for every tefillah rather it seems that if…
6. 2:37the kaffercheim and allowed the 11th men to live without securing a replacement because there is…
7. 3:08regarding any place which does not always have ten in the shore people may be compelled…
8. 3:40learning mushy feinstein was asked regarding a shul that was missing a minion only during the…
9. 4:13responsibility that the shul have ten men for the minion every day shavita levy as well…
10. 4:46that one who has committed to being the 10th men at a local minion when only…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.