Pesachim 12a-b - The Margin of Error for Witnesses - Gemarah Pesachim #53

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi YY Jacobson’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

the yeshiva dotnet you'd raise them at Aleph the wine starts katoa solo shows huh sir marshal midway down the Ummat you see the end of the wise turn on how your voice can I say Bashevis curious something tomorrow it's 9:00 we learned the Mishnah which mission is this this is the same mission and that we have been exploring misaki-san hadron def mem armored Aleph v the opening of the fifth chapter of my sector sunedra where we learned the argument between w hooda arab mayor about testimony the Mishnah said that if two witnesses come and one says the second day of the month he saw this event and the second witness says he saw on the third day it's valid but if it's day two day three and day five it's invalid with hours somebody said the second hour he saw the event and the other person says it happened the third hour when they're examined independently so then the aid this is valid but if he says the second hour the third hour and the other eight says the fifth hour then Rev mayor says the aid this is invalid it's bottle review de argued and said even third hour and fifth are the two witnesses say these two hours and there's a discrepancy between three and five the ADA's is still upheld unless one says the fifth hour one says the seventh hour and then it's not upheld

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00the yeshiva dotnet you'd raise them at Aleph the wine starts katoa solo shows huh sir…
2. 6:30cycle of Schmitt the right before you evil that's number one so now we year No…
3. 12:50color unless it's a color that can be mistaken that would work sometimes you have two…
4. 19:17the instrument he used for murder their album says has not because its appearance and we…
5. 25:40you heard in one of the cities that two people went and they influenced the majority…
6. 32:12come see round the darkest when it comes up with his own when it comes to…
7. 38:40for example the exact hour so to aid this cannot come and be mazing me and…
8. 45:13maybe it's the end of the second hour which means eight o'clock right eight o'clock and…
9. 51:34he meant 759 right so you're given fun so it could be 759 see if you…
10. 57:598:59 with 11:59 no problem it happened 11:59 is still lying you know why you're with…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.