Chazarah - Chullin Daf 69 | Nothing but the Daf with R' Eli Stefansky

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Eli Stefansky’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

[music] Good morning. Yesterday we discussed this case. That's basically what we're discussing today and that is that a pregnant animal you doan you don't have to perform to the fetus because that's called a benua. But what if the animal the fetus stuck its leg out for a moment and then brought it back in? So we saw yesterday between and back in? So we saw yesterday between and Rav says that part that came out you can't eat that was already born that little part and when you bring it back into the body the mother doesn't apply to that part says no there's no such thing you could you could do to the mother and you could even that part. So let's see how it looks like. This is Rav Rav says the peace that comes out is they say these words basically the same they say these words basically the same exact thing just different words when that limb goes out it was born. You can't unborn something. If a child is born you can't put it back in in its mother's stomach and say oh it wasn't born. It was born. Can't there's no that's it. It's that it's over. The leg came out, it was born. Another length, leg came out, it was born. The question is why is it said in different words? It's the same exact thing addresses that thing addresses that they say slightly different. The same idea but different words once the the the hand the leg both come out. Yesterday somebody came over to me in the Shir and said it's only the hand because the leg makes it a not true. It could be anything says there's no such thing as one limb being born. You need a you need something substantial.

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01[music] Good morning. Yesterday we discussed this case. That's basically what we're discussing today and that…
2. 3:11born that's what's according to the second that it's a lea it's a birth so it…
3. 6:51finishes off. Here's the total rule. If it's part of the mother animal, like her kidney,…
4. 9:59have an animal inside the dotted line. In a way those dotted lines are a forum…
5. 13:37Oh, this is bad. >> Then he shifted the second one. See here the Shiloh. Here's…
6. 16:51thing minus its front leg. Why? Because that front leg never it stuck it out before…
7. 20:26So the question is do we say that the father the father's leg goes into the…
8. 23:41anyway is awesome. There's no problem of you don't have three and according to everybody you…
9. 27:27and not that's a fetus to the limbs of kachum. It has to be full animals.…
10. 31:04and then it says talking about so are connected. If you look at the purple in…

Every second of this shiur plays inside FilteredTube — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.