Maseches Chullin Daf 75, Daf Yomi with Rabbi Phil Karesh

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Daf Yomi with Rabbi Phil Karesh’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Good evening. Hope you're all doing well. Today we are learning and we're starting about 34s of the way down about four lines before the wide lines. Yesterday in the Mishna uh Mishna that started on the bottom of we learned about a a fascinating tano that hovered around whether or not there really is in fact a den of Ben Pakua. Of course, if a mother is and there is a a fetus in udo mother is and there is a a fetus in udo and that fetus survives, so does that child does that child require? We saw a three-way mloim. We saw the opinion of Rayor that really there is no paka and really this fetus even though its mother was while the fetus was still connected. The fetus that became a ch that became a child needs its own. We saw the shittita of the that it does not require. And then we saw the shizuri that even if it was five years old, it that even if it was five years old, it wouldn't require. Of course, we're going to ask on those last two shittas because they're very similar. We're going to see a couple of questions that as we always do in that kind of pushes the limits and tries to help us to clarify what the scope and breadth of these are. Let's get started. We have a question that was asked in the base medar that we'll soon see in as well as you know there is a that says that when it comes to a kamore a

Jump to a moment

1. 0:02Good evening. Hope you're all doing well. Today we are learning and we're starting about 34s…
2. 3:35because we say that when the mother was so therefore it's as though the child was…
3. 7:40is a that even though it has to be but when it comes to we allow…
4. 11:50three lines from the bottom on the if an animal walks through a river. Now that…
5. 15:24we saw the shittita above that we need between the two entities that's a from the…
6. 19:33according to the says that a ta doesn't necessarily die. So why is this question about…
7. 23:43because What causes the animal to become a behemoth? Gestation 9 months whatever. I think we've…
8. 27:20in regards to the so this is a fascinating thing it's a conceptual argument because the…
9. 31:28of we're in the camp of the so you can either the of the mother or…
10. 35:42rabbon. Rashi here points this out. Rashi is about 12 lines down. They still do they…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.