Yerushalmi Makkos 3a 5784

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Yosef Gavriel Bechhofer’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Molly you have an alarm for your Tor okay guys we'll wait a couple minutes to see uh anybody else comes okay so we're on the over here right after the Mish so uh the um the uh thear here is talking about when and how a z comes possible so um the uh says this teaches us this is really going on in in thei the there talks about as the same exact except that there it's there are fewer mistakes in the geara than there are over here but thear there is is talking about and that the ad become hled for if they testified on the of the animal that the animal was slaughtered or sold and they became p on that because for the testimony on the G assuming it's the same same it's the same um it's the same uh the same the testimony together that's going to discuss right now so okay that talk about one part of a testimony or also the other part of testimony that that's a fascinating thing now B what does that mean mean eight comes to Bas then eight called the B so there are two ways of looking at it one is that Bon now determines that this person is an A in which case they um uh retroactively from the time of his testimony and everything he said since that testimony the um but the thei saying no and B doesn't make him puzzle He makes himself pule what's what does that mean so what is he pule for only for any testimony he testified at the time he was testifying his false testimony and it's anything he said at the same time

Jump to a moment

1. 0:03Molly you have an alarm for your Tor okay guys we'll wait a couple minutes to…
2. 3:17but everybody else can hear right yeah I can hear I'm just relaying the message uh…
3. 7:06is another uh two or three payments depending on whether it's a sure or a set…
4. 10:55the same time right other words it t together but this this this gar is saying…
5. 14:26testify them and then they become pule after but not not not retroactively okay so and…
6. 18:27here if they're going to testify uh uh in one uh uh time then you can't…
7. 22:12here they came on one year second year third year and that's why we can accept…
8. 25:37say as the other as the first two the if the gave such a punishment the…
9. 29:26is so tell me one or not the other why didn't he tell me both so…
10. 33:37special din by of means you have to try and save the life right if you…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.