Makos Daf 8

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Moshe Meir Weiss’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

my should. We uh we we uh are going to start from the Mishna on Dam Bish. The Mishna says, "If the uh somebody is uh chopping with an axe and the blade flies off the handle, so that's who who would be doing that." And we want to welcome in Danny Vogel. Wow. It's wonderful to have you, Danny. Uh it's it's certainly tremendous to have you join us and uh and hold on. I'm saying shar here. Shash here. Shashi here. It it um it's good to be here. It's been a little challenging with uh the youngest and unpacking and Okay. Well, Danny, it's good it's good to have you Danny Vogu. Thank you. uh who uh who has has been in my sh 40 years ago. 40 years ago. Uh uh and uh anyway, so who who would do it? Somebody like uh somebody like Marshall Castle, right? and he's he's holding an axe and he chops with the axe and it flies the handle flies out of his hand uh and the handle flies the excuse me the the uh blade flies off the handle and kills and kills says that's not a case of exile he does go into exile Now here Marshall is chopping wood and a piece of wood flies out from the tree as a projectile and kills. In that case says that he goes into exile and the say he doesn't go into exile. So now the says okay so let's see what's at stake over here. The question is how do we learn a does it say that the blade slipped off from its wood namely from the handle? It

Jump to a moment

1. 1:12my should. We uh we we uh are going to start from the Mishna on Dam…
2. 5:04Um, it's talking about the tree that is being chopped. So, Rebi says when Marshall chops…
3. 8:50generated by his initial coak by his initial uh strength here where he throws the clad…
4. 12:33ordin or an agent of court that's administering punishment if they kill since they're doing it.…
5. 16:21redeem back this field close by or to sell a a poor uh not so good…
6. 20:03makeup. Even if the child learns, it's still a mitzvah to give him some discipline. If…
7. 23:45says from plowing and harvesting you should rest. Now, it already says that you're not allowed…
8. 27:39just like plowing. If you found it plowed, you don't have to plow. Uh so also…
9. 31:28learning says we said that it's a mitzvah to give him discipline even if he's learning…
10. 35:27aidi and ausi uh they they are go into exile and this is according to the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.