Yeshiva Daf | Chulin 10 | Rav Yechezkel Hartman

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Okay. Welcome to Shiur Daf. We're We're learning today Chulin Daf Yud. We're starting from the two dots about um 10 lines from the top of the amud. The exact Yeah, 11 that 11 We're starting on the on the 11th line. Says the Gemara, "Itma. Ha shocheit be sakin ve nitza says pogum. Someone went and used a sakin, used a Someone went and used a sakin, used a knife for shechita, and then he find that the the knife was pogum. It was not smooth. And it could make the animal treif all. Kol v'lo af ilu shiber bo atzmos kol ayan. Even if he broke bones, meaning after the shechita, he went and he used the knife to break bones. Pasul. Chashinan shema v'or nefgam. So, to explain it, there is basically two ways that the there is basically two ways that the knife can become pogum. It could be that you have the skin, you have the skin on the animal, and you're shechting the animal, the skin while while he's doing the shechita on the skin, he already is making the sakin pogum. Then he does the shechita. Afterwards, he goes and he uses the knife to cut to cut bones. I don't know where he made the sakin pogum. Was it in the skin before the shechita, or was it the bones after shechita?

Jump to a moment

1. 0:02Okay. Welcome to Shiur Daf. We're We're learning today Chulin Daf Yud. We're starting from the…
2. 2:34the animal is also. So now he's taking the the knife trying to sharpen it. You…
3. 5:36Meaning it went to the miracle. I don't know now if it was before and after.…
4. 8:40um So, there the the And what what is the vadai That's that's going back to…
5. 11:42sheet of the sharia, you have to check both simanim. By a bird, one siman is…
6. 14:47again in the animal not in the knife. So what do you do with this? My…
7. 17:20So the Reish the etzma mafkeid the mafkeid is the back of is the neck. It's…
8. 20:25After the first one. So the first one was kosher. In other words, there was 30…
9. 23:30So, in other Look at Look at the Look at the middle middle of the of…
10. 26:36What? So he goes out to us. One second maybe during the time he's going out.…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.