Parshas Emor: "When A Rabbi Is Accused of Heresy"

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

this world impartials emma talks about kidder shashem and what we're going to speak about today is probably the most sensitive and delicate subject in jewish history rabbinic controversy now whenever there's been a controversy there's always a major issue of hashem especially when a great rav or a great goddess accused of uh a fundamental lack not only amidst observance but in the usa now now what do we do with him so the higher the caliber of the goddamn higher the caliber of the rub the more difficult the situation becomes if you have a rav face you know a rookie and he's in some small startup shul so what's the big deal you get rid of him yeah he's gone he's gone the next day i but you didn't prove anything you don't have to prove anything uh you know that's it there's there's no uh the repercussions are not really that severe the more serious the god though the more serious there of you have to be very careful because if you take down this personage coming down with him is the whole esteem in the whole prestige of rabbanus and rabbinic judaism and kalatarakula but what do you do you leave the rav in there what are you supposed to do what's worse is it worse to have a great god of israel who is lacking the sade amuna or is it worse to take him down publicly and by taking him down it brings down all the whole bonus and the whole kabarat torah now let me just begin by saying the kavanagh in presenting the sheer is only to uphold and to elevate

Jump to a moment

1. 0:30this world impartials emma talks about kidder shashem and what we're going to speak about today…
2. 6:07that already when the who is the father of rabbiakavemden published the viennese and ibishus was…
3. 12:13he loses the job so he had you know just basically packed his bags to go…
4. 18:22never no we'll never have we'll never have answers but yeah there were basically um three…
5. 24:33wait a second how did it get to bezdin what do you think you think in…
6. 30:50they're kadash for tahar you can't leave these things hanging around by the way you know…
7. 37:14rejected by ruby acaba and i ask you what do you think the noida who the…
8. 43:22yehuda held that because of hashem it's not kedai to you know face reverence and irish…
9. 49:41a little curious because the controversy was in the 1750s and a letter was found a…
10. 55:53and we can't even give such a share about it we're just going into the mind…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.