Beki'in Bahalacha 6 - Shiur 62: Siman 160: 35Water fit for Netillat Yadayim

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Eli Mansour’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We're in the this is the MRAI edition dedicated by his sons dedicated for the study of Dany Shalom 6 edition. Uh today is day and we do have a dedication for 62 that's going to be for my good friend Simoa Shin Shin Shalom Sha dedicated by our great student David Escava and his family. So tonight we have our work cut out for us. Not a uh an easy uh entry today. That's why I wanted to get it done so our members can analyze it and study it and I'll tell you a funny story at the end. Everything is so here we discuss obviously with water but let's say you don't have water. Are you allowed to use other beverages? So all of this begins really in a gim page 50 and it starts with a rabbi called that says one can use undiluted wine for or to wash his hands I should say and or to wash his hands I should say and argue and they say that you cannot use wine now even if it's undiluted There's a big discussion if this is even talking about at all. There's a great rabbi called um it's brought down by a rabbi called a and he says just talking about washing your hands for cleanliness but for no way. He says for sure you would not be able to use wine be able to use wine whatsoever. And if you want to know where this opinion is found in you open up and I have it in front of me. We had over here on the trip so was able to use it in is going to bring three opinions here. But let's go to the first opinion.

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00We're in the this is the MRAI edition dedicated by his sons dedicated for the study…
2. 2:04be able to use wine whatsoever. And if you want to know where this opinion is…
3. 5:21shouldn't use it or technically it it should be okay I take that back it should…
4. 8:01the okay somebody says who's the somebody over here. Oh the famous page 50. So what…
5. 10:03he wants to say that me fruit juice is considered like water and therefore except wine…
6. 12:40here. When Maran says, you know, Yeshmed, you know, some say this and some say that,…
7. 15:19the second opinion would be 100% okay uh and our brings down other opinions that want…
8. 17:23doesn't agree with that. He holds that beer could be a problem but again according to…
9. 19:58or tea or coffee and that's the way also that if someone has no other choice…
10. 22:31would seem that it is permissible to use lemon lime soft drink and recite the blessing.…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.