Asking others to perform Melochos on Shabbos that you can�t do - Shiur by Rabbi Simcha Bunim Berger

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Simcha Bunim Berger’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Okay, good evening my Rabbi Sai. Another Shir in Kadusha Shabas this week. The Shir is asking your friend to do something for you that you yourself can't do. Let me give you a few examples. How about if a person has it has the taken the he can't he or she doesn't open up he can't he or she doesn't open up bottles on chabas any of the plastic plastic covers can you ask someone else your friend doesn't have that or doesn't have that I'm be careful if I call it ara yet can you ask your friend to open the bottom for me. Seeing that you can't do it, that means that it's user for you to do this. Is it also for you to tell him? He could do it cuz he doesn't have that cuz could do it cuz he doesn't have that cuz he pass. Give you another example. When food that was hot on Shabas begins to cool down. It's a do. It's a do and it gets cooler, but it's not room temperature yet. It's warmer than room temperature. It's still warm because the heat that had would generate is still prevalent in the food. generate is still prevalent in the food. the rakins you can put it back on a hot plate and it's not a problem of bishel theor the b and the asser it's mut for an ashkanazi but it's user for aari can thei asks the ashkanazi to put the food back on because for the ashkanazi he's not doing anything wrong but for the sardi it is so is out of

Jump to a moment

1. 0:03Okay, good evening my Rabbi Sai. Another Shir in Kadusha Shabas this week. The Shir is…
2. 3:42person who has on himself an iser regarding is shabas but is does not have that…
3. 7:59you can only say things that are permissible. We're not going to talk about Amir's akumn…
4. 12:14there's only one minion and one cababas shabas then everybody's on board that person you ask…
5. 16:23now but it's not for not necessarily have to be out of bounds so it's not…
6. 20:31words of the B. But what do you mean? Take a look at the B and…
7. 24:53person. This is the quote from the you're allowed to ask your friend to do the…
8. 29:04You know what I think says? I disagree. I think Shabas is worse. I think you…
9. 33:26hold its user to open bottles, but he holds its mut to open bottles. Can I…
10. 37:52the person, your friend doesn't have to be like you. A person who's the other person…

Every second of this shiur plays inside FilteredTube — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.