2b1 Masechet Makkot - Amud Yomi

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shlomo Yisraeli’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We are continuing on and we the top of the about 13 lines down from the top of the is being learned that should have full recovery so just a quick recap the m about the cases that do not get what they try to do to the other person general rule is if you try to get someone a certain punishment and then you become which means that the another group of say you could not have testified that Reuben killed Shimon on Tuesday morning at 9:00 in Los Angeles because Tuesday morning at 9:00 you guys the two edim you were with us in friends you could not have been in Los Angeles so therefore they become Z and we kill them so that's the general rule if they wanted to kill someone they intended to kill they get killed if they intended to make him pay they pay but there are two examples that the Mish said that we do not punish the punishment they wanted to inflict on that that person that fellow but rather they observe the 39 lashes a set of Mal from the Torah what are those two cases one is if they testify on aen that he's not a he's a Ben say oh we remember before he was conceived his mother was a divorced woman so he was born from a divorce and therefore he is not a Coen he is a Coen then we don't we no longer do because you can't do it it's a technical Dr log you cannot you cannot apply that on because it

Jump to a moment

1. 0:04We are continuing on and we the top of the about 13 lines down from the…
2. 2:49witnesses come and they say this fellow should go to galut should go to one of…
3. 6:08white it says that they get whatever they intended to give to their brother says how…
4. 8:52Man Wicked you lash the wicked person no not always you don't always get lashes sometimes…
5. 12:05testifying on that maybe they did maybe they didn't but you could not have witnessed that…
6. 15:17getting Mal so what did they do the first group of forget about for just a…
7. 18:02no you don't get lashes you lied right you lied and I could prove it you…
8. 21:23mean that you kill it it means speaking of right spirit he gets you don't kill…
9. 24:06become but you also have to pay so says what is this payment that means if…
10. 27:22together you pay this Cofer and it's so it says you pay the worth of the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.