Shavuos: The Shaagos Aryeh on Birchas Hatorah D'Oiraisa or D'rabbanan

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Top rest. Okay, friends. We have an amazing timely topic today in preparation for the Yom Tov of Shavuot. And a gishmaka maracha in the Shagas Ariye. And it also, don't tell anyone, happens to be the Bar Mitzvah of Shetel of Naftali Aaron Goldstein. So, I pulled that from my notes. It's a very very uh timely, relevant, and literally on the page of our Gemara. The Gemara says on Nedarim Perek Aleph, The Gemara says on Nedarim Perek Aleph, U'mibnei Ma'in metzuyin talmidei chachamim letzei's talmidei chachamim mibneihem. Why are Torah sages Do why do they not frequently produce talmidei chachamim? Amar Rav Yosef, "Shelo yomru Torah yerusha hi lahem." So, that people don't say they have ownership over it. And that they inherited it. Rav Sheishta said Rav Idi omer, "Kedei shelo yisgagu ala tzibbur." So, they don't come to dominate, domineer. Mar Zutra omer, "Mibnei shehein misgabrin ala tzibbur." shehein misgabrin ala tzibbur." As a punishment for domineering the tzibbur. Rav Ashi omer, "Mishum dikaru le'inshei chamarei." They called people donkeys. Ravina omer, "She'ein mevarhin betorah techila." Ravina says because they don't make birchas haTorah. Da amar Rav Yehuda amar Rav, "Mai disiv, 'Mi ha'ish hahacham veyavineihu zos?'" Davar zeh nishal lechachamim velanevi'im. This matter was asked to the sages and the prophets. Velo peirshu, they didn't explain it. Ach peirshu, they didn't explain it. Ach peirshu Hakadosh Baruchu ba'atzmo, dichsiv, "Vayomer Hashem el Ozam es Torasi." Hainu lo sham'u bekoli, hainu lo halchu ba. Amar Rav Yehuda amar Rav, "She'ein mevarhin betorah techila." Now, I want you to take notice of the Why talmidei chachamim don't frequently produce talmidei chachamim? Rav Yosef, Rav Sheishes,

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00Top rest. Okay, friends. We have an amazing timely topic today in preparation for the Yom…
2. 2:34because he's mentioned after Rav Ashi. Okay? Just take note of that. The topic we're going…
3. 5:08the mitzvos de'oraisa. And the Shaagas Aryeh is troubled why? If you look in the next…
4. 7:40Madach Torah you don't make a bracha after You make a bracha before. M' zayin that…
5. 10:24is the right show. And that would only make sense if because that Torah before was…
6. 13:36By the way, the pre-K in our semen mem Zion brings the same Raya. Here the…
7. 16:19only [clears throat] if he's equal or greater than the other talmid chacham in present. But…
8. 18:53Even though Ravina in Brachos holds it's d'Rabbanan. And it's not a stira because that's Ravina…
9. 21:27the punishment of someone who makes who doesn't make Berachot Torah is very great. Could somebody…
10. 24:00night, yeish omdim d'ein tzorech l'varech baboker. There are some say you don't have to make…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.