R' Yitzchak Shifman | Megilla 4b-5a (top)

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Shul․com’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

okay today we're learning we're going to begin at the two dots about 10 12 lines from the top of the page we're going to have three sections in today's learning first section we're going to clarify why the mishna seems to reverse the introduction and then how it explains as it continues the second section will discuss two that could conform with the of the Mish regarding the falling out on Friday and then the third section we'll discuss is not reading Mig Shabbat sorry and a fourth section is going to be regarding when Pim falls out or the m is read not in its time is there what what's the reality in terms of having not having we'll get to that also at the end so let's get started from the two dots now we had said in the m very irregular thing usually when the mishna introduces a topic it'll introduce it in a certain order and then it will discuss it in the same order that's the usual thing this first part of the mishna says Mig is read on the 11th 12th 13th 14th and 15th but when it discusses it does not illustrate in the mishna how it's read on the 11th 12th 13th 14th and 15th let me illustrate how Rashi explains it if you look it actually illustrates the opposite it doesn't illustrate on the dates of the month which would be 11 12

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01okay today we're learning we're going to begin at the two dots about 10 12 lines…
2. 2:39the way it lays it out in the beginning that's the question usually it's it's there's…
3. 5:52Shabbat you can't read on Shabbat we'll see later in this Su so the wall cities…
4. 9:03standard that you should also uphold so maybe you shouldn't push the unwalled cities back to…
5. 11:43like no the wal cities cannot read the day before the unwalled cities rather both of…
6. 14:57just shown like our mishna he said that when you have Friday being the 14th the…
7. 18:0815th what it has to mean in the Bri is anything that's being pushed back is…
8. 20:48poor on the day that we read M earlier supports this even though they said the…
9. 24:04only kept things on the they didn't have to keep those things tells us because the…
10. 27:20miracle says now the way Rashi explains like this there's a even B even on the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.