MENTION AND OMISSION OF CHANUKAH IN THE MISHNA - Shiur by Rabbi Nachum Scheiner

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Nachum Scheiner’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

the we're learning now. But today's shir is not on the daff. It's the Gomorrah says ai nimala. I know we're in Kaneka but the Gmorrah says the razor and Kaneka together so we could speak Porm also. The Gomorrah says just like the the crack of dawn in the morning is the end of the night. The story of Esther it's the end of the fractur the story of Purim is the last nest is the nest of Kaneka that happened later Purim the story of Puram happened later Purim the story of Puram happened between Bayas and Bayeni right before Bayeni the story of Kaneka happened about 200 years later 200 years into Bay Sheni So freom what do you mean this the nest of purim is the last nest that happened later in the year first comes then pumm but pur happened a good 200 years earlier what does it mean what does it mean the last mess in the history of Israel that's written down inav is pur of course the early in the but then later on in is written these other n that happened the last nest to be written down is migill that's the last nest and yuma so we understand why there is no mention so we understand why there is no mention of cuz Esther was the end like the Gomorrah says the end however is why is there no that's the who wrote the Mishna wrote it after means at least 200 years after.

Jump to a moment

1. 0:03the we're learning now. But today's shir is not on the daff. It's the Gomorrah says…
2. 2:43means at least 200 years after. So why is there no makas? Why is there no…
3. 5:21is n to know when pes is ztoishna and kisl to know when kanuka is so…
4. 8:09So the shil is why isn't there that speak about inh that's recorded from theam says…
5. 10:56this Ramban but the Ramban says that it was a Tina even though they were and…
6. 14:10there's one piece of all of that doesn't have it doesn't have it you take a…
7. 16:46with this ter. But the em is that himself in asked this question and he has…
8. 19:27like the way he says it that everyone knows it everybody does it everybody wears fillin…
9. 22:09raam another terret the says that it's actually yes written where's it written we the gammorra…
10. 24:46we do have kanek we do have kanek so here says explains asks the gmorrah says…

Every second of this shiur plays inside FilteredTube — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.