Halacha vs Kabbalah Who Wins When They Disagree 05 18 2025

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Yoel Plutchok’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

details of the integration of z into or kabala into now really that could take us a year to discuss. Um there's dozens probably probably probably hundreds already of occurrences where um Kabala has has you know morphed into or integrated itself in in particular like in um less so like in you know but more in in such um in particular there are several individuals whose approach to Kabala individuals whose approach to Kabala itself is worthy of a sharel the start starting let's say from from the the the um the buras etc etc there's many many different people whose just their position itself on the integration of worthy of a so what I'm going to try to do is just give a little bit of like the building blocks of this discussion and obviously we're not going to be able to get to to even close to everything today um I want to start as follows in 1950 um I want to start as follows in 1950 the rabbi not published a list of takanas. They made takas for the whole rabbanut. Um it was signed by rahertzag and raviel. These were the two chief rabbis at the time and they made a few like rules. They wanted to standardize certain practices for all of one of the things that they standardized is as follows. They said that if the should present itself where there's a situation that needs right meaning i.e someone dies without children they have brothers. So the terra gives two remedies for that. They see the mahalita should such

Jump to a moment

1. 0:31details of the integration of z into or kabala into now really that could take us…
2. 3:06later like uh of a masterpiece of a chuva probably 10 12 pages of like just…
3. 6:12man in his 30s a young Ashkanazi probably maybe from maybe from Ashkanaz itself r by…
4. 8:46I think it's that says someone We have [snorts] it's ethical examples of total total lack…
5. 12:02that was all shoot straight down the line. Today he says we have the zire and…
6. 15:10And the second question was could you say about himself this is from the earliest he'…
7. 17:46if everybody's coming with a peck with a package or something that has to be resolved…
8. 20:53or eight rias to this, but his first two rias that is purely from the that's…
9. 23:30and if I'm able to I venture to say we probably could say it's much the…
10. 26:34what the gun didn't allow. Additionally the at least it seems to be the quoted by…

Every second of this shiur plays inside FilteredTube — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.