The Lomdus of "Mai Chanukah"

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

more precisely what does it mean what is kanaka for what miracle was it established for what miracle was it established what's rashi bothered by for what miracle was it established rashi is bothered by that there were two miracles on chanukah one miracle was the miracle of the military victory the the war of the military victory the the miracle of the military victory and one was the um the miracle of the oil so what the kumar was asking is for which one of the two miracles do we say how well do we say hello for the military victory or do we say hallel for the miracle of the oil but more specifically what the kumar is asking is we know about the military victory but we know you're not allowed to say hollow for military victory why not because military victory is not an open miracle if you win a war two soldiers against a million soldiers it's not an open miracle because you could always explain it you could always analyze it you could always say well they had a better uh strategic uh a point of war and therefore it's not an open miracle what the kumar is asking is we need an open miracle to be able to say hello that is why in this century many goddard said that even if the uh i'm leaving seconds whatever that even if the state of israel is miraculous most good islam said not to say hello for the war of independence for that for this reason that even if it is

Jump to a moment

1. 0:32more precisely what does it mean what is kanaka for what miracle was it established for…
2. 2:36when the greeks entered the hecal temu they defiled all the oil in the this is…
3. 5:22the answer is which means if you move something it's considered like you touched it yeah…
4. 7:59100 years the miracle of kanaka how many years did it happen before the destruction of…
5. 10:04that have the status of azov okay that means if you're speaking to a gentile and…
6. 12:49they they they may have used the parabola zara okay but now this is where i…
7. 15:45is pointing out is that how could the gemara say when the ivanim entered the hekhar…
8. 17:58they couldn't use you can use it for the um yeah is there a plan there's…
9. 20:47that wherever there's the law of yihood we say suffic tame is tame wherever there's no…
10. 23:34then okay one more answer i have a question let's get back to the original question…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.